Review: Award winner with heaps to smile about

A ten-minute train journey from Sheffield brings you to the delights of Chesterfield, and in a mock-Tudor building on Knifesmithgate lies Bottle and Thyme.

Wednesday, 8th November 2017, 14:51 pm
Updated Tuesday, 12th December 2017, 09:54 am
Bottle and Thyme food review for Sheffield Star - staff Ella Platts, Hugh Hudson, Josh Feeley, Shane Gower, Guy Meddows-Taylor, Gavin Grainger and Hannah Grainger

Firstly, a couple of Long Island ice teas were brought to our table by the smiling waitress, and you really can see why this restaurant scooped the customer service award at the recent Chesterfield Food and Drinks Awards.

They also brought home the best newcomer award, having been open for just under a year.

Bottle and Thyme food review for Sheffield Star - Lunch Sweetcorn Fritters with mild tomato salsa and sour cream with added avocado

There are a fair few choices on the menu for vegetarians.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

I opted for the goat’s cheese and caramelised onion starter for £5.

This was two puff pastry rounds with a generous portion of subtly flavoured caramelised onion topped with goat’s cheese and served with a balsamic drizzle.

Tim had the soup of the day ( £4.50).

Bottle and Thyme food review for Sheffield Star - Breakfast Pancakes with mixed berries, greek yoghurt and local Derbyshire Honey

That classic French onion soup was served piping hot with two huge wedges of soft, fresh bread, a hearty winter warmer to start our November evening.

For mains, it had to be the butternut squash risotto ( £9).

This creamy dish arrived with a topping of crispy kale and an impressively huge round of goat’s cheese, melting in the middle.

It was a struggle to finish the large portion but it was perfectly cooked with chunks of roasted butternut squash to add a bit of bite.

Bottle and Thyme food review for Sheffield Star - Lunch Sweetcorn Fritters with mild tomato salsa and sour cream with added avocado

Tim’s veggie burger (£9.50) was presented beautifully on a plate with a large side salad and chunky twice-cooked chips with skins on.

The burger was two large earthy field mushrooms, beetroot, spinach and goat’s cheese, all complimentary flavours served within a brioche bun.

The staff were very efficient in serving the courses and checking everything was satisfactory, even on a busy Friday evening.

I had to try the salted caramel brownie, where gooey caramel was swirled among a moist chocolate brownie and topped with a ball of salted caramel ice cream and a dusting of toasted hazelnut crumb, plus forest fruits with a fruit coulis.

Bottle and Thyme food review for Sheffield Star - Breakfast Pancakes with mixed berries, greek yoghurt and local Derbyshire Honey

I think owner Gavin Grainger and partner Hannah have got this place just right. Gavin takes pride in the menu choices and the locally sourced produce they use, including his chef’s home-grown vegetables.

The total bill was £49 including drinks which is great value for money.

Heartily recommended.