Review: A Christmas Carol at the Crucible, Sheffield
It would be bah humbug indeed to criticise A Christmas Carol, Sheffield Theatres’ lovely-to-look-at big Crucible production for the 2025 festive season.
After all, have the spirits taught us nothing, if not to honour Christmas in our hearts with goodwill to all men… even those who talk in West Yorkshire accents when they’re meant to be from Sheffield, or are simply too nice to convince as Scrooge, the wizened miser whose idea of supper was ‘a little saucepan of gruel’.


And so let us keep to the plentiful positives about this perfectly pleasant, Sheffield-centric Christmassy show, sumptuous with velvet capes and fur muffs, largely faithful to Dickens’ much-loved tale, and which manages – like the peerless Muppets before it – to pull off a unique take on the oft-performed classic.
In this adaptation, from director Elin Schofield and writer Aisha Khan, the setting shifts cleverly from Victorian London to Victorian Sheffield, where the Christmas carol is our city’s own tradition of village carols – an oral heritage of communally-sung local songs kept alive in the pubs of north Sheffield to this day. (It is fitting that, until Sunday at least, Crucible audiences arrive to the mellow voice of Pete McKee echoing around Tudor Square for illumination installation Light Up Sheffield. His warm accent and affectionate Sheffield reflections set the perfect tone.)


So, in a festive mash-up of Flying Pickets yodelling and a-capella carolling, the play begins with the multi-part cast harmonising heartily as they fill the stage beneath an excellent split-level wooden scaffolding set.
Scrooge is played by Ian Midlane, who you might recognise as Al from daytime soap Doctors.
But he is too distractingly portly – and jarringly jovial – to persuade as the pinched-face Ebenezer we know. When he berates clerk Bob Cratchit (a likeable Ryan O’Donnell, who doubles as Young Ebenezer) for requesting Christmas Day off, it’s with almost jolly joshing rather than menace-laced cruelty.
Perhaps we are to view Scrooge more as self-satisfied northern capitalist than merely mean money-lender? The cast dance a jig to local ‘carol’ Six Jolly Miners, which contrasts bitterly the wealth of foundry giants Newton Chambers with their thousands of impoverished workers. But there are just not enough South Yorkshire references to make you ponder any parallels very deeply.


The ghosts, when they appear, to guide Scrooge towards redemption, are not as scary as the U-rating visitations that menace Michael Caine in the Muppets – and nowhere near as terrifying as the tattered spectres from the Northern Ballet’s version at The Lyceum last year.
The transformation of Scrooge’s door-knocker into dead-to-begin-with business partner Marley is fun, not frightening. Adam Price is more successful as dear old Fezziwig than as the camp Ghost of Christmas Present.
Mel Lowe, veteran of Crucible triumphs Standing at the Sky’s Edge and A Doll’s House, plays boy narrator Jack (Rizzo the Rat from the Muppets, if you will), who tells Scrooge’s story to a competent cohort of children from various Sheffield and Barnsley stage schools. But Lowe’s Artful Dodger-ish entrances break the atmosphere each time, giving the play a sometimes thigh-slapping panto feel.
Is that a bad thing? It is Christmas after all (God bless us, everyone) and a pretty snowflake finale draws gasps of delighted wonder as the show draws to a rousing carolling close.


But overall the impression is of pleasing, anodyne, festive entertainment for all the family – rather than the truly creative piece of re-inventive local theatre A Christmas Carol could perhaps have been.









