Adam Reach had earlier given the Owls the lead in rather fortunate circumstances, but how did the Wednesday players fare in the 1-1 draw? Our man at the game, Danny Hall, gives his ratings.
Kieron Westwood - 6. No chance with Barnley's goal, and did well earlier to push McGeehan's effort past his post
Jack Hunt - 7. Very good going forward and also snuffed out a dangerous Barnsley attack with a superb covering tackle
Remembering 'beautiful' and 'amazing' Blake and Tristan Barrass three years on from tragic Sheffield brothers' funeral
Sheffield Council employees sacked as fraud increases including theft and excessive internet use during work
EuroMillions: Mystery winner from South Yorkshire has won £79,242.50 on The National Lottery
Power cut Sheffield: Hundreds of homes in Hillfoot area without power ahead of 28C heatwave today
Sheffield Council tenant forced to pay £5,000 and struck from housing register for fraud
Tom Lees - 6. Twice should have scored with a header and did well at the other end to snuff out a dangerous Bradshaw chance
Joost van Aken - 6. Comfortable on the ball but beaten too easy by Bradshaw. Booked for cynical foul on Thiam
Daniel Pudil - 6. Looked determined to seize his chance, but was replaced after picking up a second-half injury
Ross Wallace - 5. Quiet throughout and one basic misplaced pass summed up his afternoon. Replaced by Joao with eight minutes left
Barry Bannan - 7. My man of the match. Two excellent bits of skill almost resulted in goals and he was a threat throughout
Kieran Lee - 6. Unlucky not to score a stunner in the first half, when he hit the woodwork. Worked tirelessly
Adam Reach - 7. Close to man of the match. Man of the first half, if you like. A constant threat and scored a fortunate goal
Gary Hooper - 6. Wasn't quite at his best but linked the play well. Had a decent chance late on
Steven Fletcher - 6. Fluffed his lines early on and dropped deep to affect play, but was a display of industry rather than invention.
Subs: Jacob Butterfield (Pudil 66), 6; Jordan Rhodes (Fletcher 74), 6; Lucas Joao (Wallace 82), 6.
Not used: Joe Wildsmith, David Jones, Liam Palmer, Frederico Venancio.
Barnsley: Adam Davies 8, Jason McCarthy 6, Angus MacDonald 7, Liam Lindsay 7, Andy Yiadom 7, Adam Hammill 6, Joe Williams 6, Cameron McGeehan 6, Harvey Barnes 7, Tom Bradshaw 6, Mamadou Thiam 6. Substitutes: Brad Potts (Thiam 45), 6. Isgrove (Hammill 66), 6. Not used: Jack Walton, Matty Pearson, Ryan Hedges, Ike Ugbo.