Public anger despite council pledges ahead of key decision on Sheffield war memorial trees

Councillors again tried to reassure residents about Sheffield's war memorial trees ahead of a decision on the future of those due to be cut down.

Wednesday, 13th September 2017, 8:44 pm
Updated Thursday, 14th September 2017, 11:20 am
Memorial trees in Oxford Street.

Tempers rose among members of the public yesterday evening as Coun Bryan Lodge told a scrutiny committee that the authority would look to restore existing memorial streets, such as Western Road, back to their original design by planting new trees to replace those lost over time.

A number of trees, including 23 in Western Road, are due to come down by the end of the year. The council says they need to be removed so highways improvements can be made as part of the Streets Ahead PFI contract with Amey.

But several people said there was no reason to fell healthy trees, and asked why money could not be found to save them. Two, Alan Story and Arthur Baker, were asked to leave after repeatedly interrupting councillors - although they were eventually allowed to stay. And Dave Dillner left of his own accord, clearly unimpressed with what he had heard.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Coun Bryan Lodge.

Cabinet members will consider the issue on Wednesday, following a report from a cross-party working group that said all memorial street trees should be treated differently.

Coun Lodge, responsible for the environment, said no decisions had yet been made, but warned work outside the contract would cost money that was not available in the highways budget.

He also highlighted plans, revealed in The Star yesterday, to plant about 300 new memorial trees in the city's parks and green spaces - as additions rather than alternatives.

Elizabeth Motley raised concerns about this plan asking why, if money was available for new trees, were others being felled?

Western Road.

"If there are solutions, couldn't we do something to raise that extra money?" she said.

This was echoed by Coun Rob Murphy, who said: "I would question the wisdom of proposals to spend money on war memorials when also talking about the financial constraints of retaining the war memorials that we have got."

Director of culture and environment Paul Billington said new park trees would come out of the existing parks budget, adding: "It is considerably cheaper than planting trees in highway situations."

On war memorial street trees, Coun Lodge said 213 had been identified across the city, of which 99 were left in the city - although there could be others that were not properly registered.

Alan Story and Arthur Baker.

He added: "What we are hoping to do is replace those that were lost and add them back in to restore the avenues to the way they were originally."

Money for replacing missing trees is available under Streets Ahead.

However, this does not mean others will not be felled if engineering solutions cannot be found within the contract.

The council is talking to the War Memorials Trust about Western Road, and head of parks and countryside Lisa Firth said there was interest, but funding could not be guaranteed.

Dave Dillner.

Councillors could also use money from their ward pots for some work, said Coun Lodge, but it would have to be a 'wise' investment.

Coun Colin Ross asked that as much information be made publicly available as possible, to avoid both suspicion and costly Freedom of Information requests. Coun Lodge agreed and said officers were working on reports for each of the 23 Western Road trees ahead of Wednesday's cabinet meeting.

He also said some of the redacted parts of the Streets Ahead contract could soon be made public.

Coun Bryan Lodge.
Western Road.
Alan Story and Arthur Baker.
Dave Dillner.