New Sheffield Reform councillor apologises for colleague's 'appalling' Nazi comments
Massively expanded party in Sheffield has faced immediate scandal
A new Sheffield Reform councillor has distanced himself from Nazi-supporting comments by a colleague after he was suspended.
Coun Matt Smith said he wanted to apologise for upset caused by Nathaniel Menday who posted online support for the Nazi party and Adolf Hitler and described some citizens as an “almost subhuman underclass.”


Coun Menday, who was elected in Woodhouse ward last week, was suspended on Wednesday after The Star uncovered extremist posts.
Coun Smith, who represents Park and Arbourthorne ward, is one of 12 new Reform councillors in Sheffield, taking the total to 13.
He said he was “appalled, frustrated and upset” by Coun Menday’s remarks and claimed he was directly involved in the suspension.
He also said Coun Menday would face a full investigation which he hoped would include “how he was allowed to stand in the first place.”
Before the poll, The Times revealed he had described Nazis as ‘real visionaries’.


Mr Smith said the posts were “unacceptable” and he had trusted those “higher up the party to take action.”
In a post on his Facebook page, Coun Smith insisted it was an “isolated incident” and condemned “any form of racism or antisemitism.”
He also said he was shocked at the amount of racism directed at residents, antisemitism in particular, while on the campaign trail.
He added: “I am not afraid of calling out racism, antisemitism or any other form of discrimination whenever I come across it, and that includes when it comes from my own team and party.
“There is simply no place for it in Britain in 2026, and certainly not here in Sheffield.”
Coun Menday’s suspension came after the Lib Dems in Sheffield called for him to be ‘sacked immediately’.


Minesh Parekh, Labour councillor for Crookes and Crosspool, called for Sheffield City Council's standards committee to “take appropriate action.”
Sheffield City Council said that because Coun Menday had been suspended by his party, it was a matter for the local Reform group.
As a local authority, the council has no ability to suspend or remove councillors, it added.
The law sets out the circumstances in which people are disqualified from being a councillor.


The authority said that if a councillor breaches its code of conduct while acting in their capacity as a councillor, the standards regime would be engaged if a complaint is received.
But it did not apply in this case as the allegations pre-date Coun Menday being elected.
Responding to Coun Smith’s post, Glenn Shaw said: “The vetting process needs reviewing, it casts a shadow on the whole party when things like this happen.”
Andrew Hizzard added: “A great statement without any doubt, heads need to roll further up the your party’s chain of command, serious questions need to be answered, but no one can hold this against local councillors.
“I look forward to hearing the facts come out and exactly who allowed Mr Menday to stand in the first place!”
John Lewis questioned whether the vetting process had failed.
He wrote: “You stated that several weeks ago you raised your “serious concerns”, and “trusting” that those higher up within the party would take appropriate action.
“As no further action was taken, it appears to me that your trust may have been misplaced.
“This raises the question of whether Reform UK’s much-publicised, costly, and supposedly “rigorous” vetting process failed, or whether the matter was deliberately overlooked by those in positions of power at a national level within Reform UK.”
