What Sheffielders think of Keir Starmer's potential successor Andy Burnham as Prime Minister

Andy Burnham is expected to be the next Prime Minister following Keir Starmer's resignation from 10 Downing Street

It’s set to be all change in British politics once again after Keir Starmer’s decision to resign from his position as Prime Minister.

Starmer became leader of the country in July 2024 following a landslide victory which put a halt to the Conservatives 14 years in power. However, he’s now decided to step aside after less than two years after many of his own party members called on him to step down and let someone else take the reins.

As it stands, most media outlets seem to be pointing towards Andy Burnham as the obvious successor at No.10 Downing Street.

Burnham, who came fourth out of five candidates in the Labour leadership election won by Ed Miliband in 2010 and second behind Jeremy Corbyn in 2015, is perhaps best known for being the Mayor of Manchester between May 2017 and June 2016 before most recently becoming an MP for Makerfield.

What do the people of Sheffield think of the prospect of Burnham leading the country. We asked our readers and this is what they had to say. (Picture: Christopher Furlong)placeholder image
What do the people of Sheffield think of the prospect of Burnham leading the country. We asked our readers and this is what they had to say. (Picture: Christopher Furlong) | Getty Images

But what do the people of Sheffield think of the prospect of Burnham leading the country. We asked our readers and this is what they had to say.

Phil Tomlinson and Ian Duke Marsh Marshall were both quick to show support for the 56-year-old. They simply commented: “Yes.” When asked if he should replace Kier Starmer.

Sarah Fidment went into more detail about why she’s backing Burnham to be a success. She said: “Totally behind Andy Burnham. I’ve seen first hand what he’s done for Manchester and if he can scale that place based leadership based on stronger place-based narrative he’s got a winning formula.

“His leadership of Greater Manchester has been built around advocacy, community identity, and a willingness to champion local interests on the national stage. Whether addressing housing, transport, health inequalities, or economic inclusion, he has consistently sought to position leadership as a vehicle for improving people’s everyday lives. So Andy has my support for keeping on championing the north and levelling up the playing field.

Chris Wright said: “Get in Andy let’s have it.”

Garry Frank Greensmith added: “Yes he has proven he is for the working man/women as mayor of Manchester.”

Mark Phillips said: “He’s Better than Farage or Starmer.”

Other were more sceptical, including Gary Dorchester

He said: “General Election is what the country wants.”

While Shirley Duff voiced her support for the Conservative Party. She said: “No, the Labour party isn't fit for government and Kemi Badenoch is the right person for the job in these unstable times.”

Dawn Wragg said: “No, give the people a say and call a general election now.”

Meanwhile, Helen Howard decided to throw another candidate into the mix. She joked: “Personally I think Larry the cat could do better.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice