Sheffield MP voices concerns over Government's new asylum plans

Labour's asylum plans could cost the beleaguered party voters, an MP from the party has warned, as backbenchers expressed scepticism about the proposals.

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood was accused of "scraping the bottom of the barrel" with her announcement yesterday, as the Government was called on to scrap the policy before it was forced into a U-turn.

Olivia Blake, Sheffield Hallam MPplaceholder image
Olivia Blake, Sheffield Hallam MP

Ms Mahmood announced on Monday that the Government would overhaul its asylum system, and make it easier to remove people with no right to be in the country.

She told MPs it was the "uncomfortable truth" that the UK's generous asylum offer, compared with other European countries, is drawing people to UK shores, and for British taxpayers the system "feels out of control and unfair".

The Conservative Party and Reform UK welcomed the announcement, but it led to Labour MPs accusing their own party of trying to "triangulate" with Nigel Farage's party.

Richard Burgon ( Leeds East) said: "I do remember when the Prime Minister pledged an immigration system based upon compassion and dignity."

He said the policy "scrapes the bottom of the barrel", adding: "Isn't this just a desperate attempt to triangulate with Reform and like some of the other terrible policy errors that have been made in recent months, is it not only morally wrong, but another policy which is set to push away Labour voters?

"Why not recognise that now, than in a few months and make a U-turn?"

Ian Lavery (Blyth and Ashington) said: "When the opposition parties, the Tories, Reform UK, not to mention that odious racist chancer, bankrolled by the world's wealthiest man, are championing our policies, is it not time to question whether we're actually in the right place?"

Ms Mahmood said: "What I would say to him is he shouldn't allow mischief-making by those that he names to throw him or our party off course."

She told Mr Burgon: "The thing that's morally wrong is knowing that you have a broken system and then pretending either that's it not broken or defending a broken status quo. I will never tolerate that."

Stella Creasy (Walthamstow) said she was concerned about the implications for children, and said refugees could face living in neverending uncertainty.

Ms Creasy said: "The Home Secretary is arguing that what will heal this divided nation is to get somebody who we have agreed is a refugee, with a well-founded fear of persecution, to feel a permanent sense of limbo because they will never be able to plan for the long term for them or their family because their status will always be uncertain because they could still face deportation."

She added 10,000 children were granted refugee status last year, but asked whether Ms Mahmood was planning to lock children up or separate them from their families as part of the plans.

Her concerns were echoed by former shadow chancellor John McDonnell , who asked if the Home Secretary had spoken to the Children's Commissioner.

Ms Mahmood replied that there are around 700 Albanian families with failed asylum claims who are not able to be deported.

"We are not going to separate parents and their children, but we are going to consult on the removal of support and how we effectively and safely ensure that those individuals are returned," she said.

She added that an equality impact assessment would be conducted.

Olivia Blake (Sheffield Hallam) had accused the Home Secretary of stoking division by saying refugees "have won a golden ticket" if they get the status in the country after fleeing "violence, war and persecution".

Ms Blake said: "Does she accept that shutting down routes for settlement will damage integration in our communities and will only strengthen Reform, not beat them?"

Meanwhile, the Home Secretary said the Government would not be taking jewellery off small boats migrants.

Sarah Owen ( Luton North ) said immigration systems do not have to be "cruel", as she said previously punitive Conservative policies had seen crossings go up.

She said: "What evidence does the Secretary of State have that taking personal belongings, such as jewellery, from refugees and selling it off, actually works as a deterrent?"

Ms Mahmood said: "The sort of case we're going after, is those who have assets, those who have access to money and who can afford quite expensive cars, who should make a contribution to the cost of what is currently free asylum support."

Brian Leishman argued "removing the legal obligation to support asylum seekers who would be otherwise destitute is as far away from Labour Party principles and values as we can get".

"I'm afraid the Government has surrendered to past discriminations and the vile rhetoric of Reform that we hear today," the Alloa and Grangemouth MP added.

Steve Witherden, MP for Montgomeryshire and Glyndwr, said the Government should "lead with compassion and fairness, not forcing some of the most vulnerable in our society to live in limbo for two decades", as he criticised changes to indefinite leave to remain.

Ms Mahmood urged both MPs "not to defend a broken status quo".

Earlier, Labour MP for Nottingham East Nadia Whittome had criticised the policies for being "dystopian".

She told the Commons: "It's shameful that a Labour Government is ripping up the rights and protections of people who have endured unimaginable trauma."

Ms Mahmood replied: "What I've said already on these matters is that we have a problem, that it is our moral duty to fix, our asylum system is broken.

"The breaking of that asylum system is causing huge division across our whole country."

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice