Sheffield developments: Householder ordered to tear down shed in Mayfield Valley green belt

The owner of a large shed in a picturesque part of Sheffield must tear it down after losing an appeal.

Sebastian Brown, of The Cottage, Old Mayfield School, on David Lane, erected a wooden building without planning permission.

The site is in green belt and an Area of High Landscape Value.

Sheffield City Council issued an enforcement notice stating it had to be removed because it was a form of ‘urban sprawl’ and harmed the view.

The shed on Mayfield Road must be torn down, the city council says.placeholder image
The shed on Mayfield Road must be torn down, the city council says. | google

Mr Brown appealed to the government’s Planning Inspectorate.

Now, inspector Grahame Kean has agreed with the city council and dismissed Mr Brown’s appeal.

Mr Kean said the shed obstructs open views and harms the ‘character and appearance’ of the street scene.

His report adds: “The appellant (Mr Brown) opines that if the outbuilding were removed, the vacant hard standing would be no more attractive.

“I disagree. It is the space within the horseshoe element (of the wall) that contributes to the character and appearance of the wider development which would be unacceptably undermined by the continued presence of the building.”

The enforcement notice requires Mr Brown to demolish and remove the building and remove any materials.

It originally gave Mr Brown two months to comply. The Planning Inspectorate’s decision date was January 7.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice