'Lib Dems have engaged in classic misinformation' Labour claims as Sheffield ambulance plans to be scrutinised

“I have spoken to ambulance crews as well as Yorkshire Ambulance Service and heard about the need for a new modern service and what consolidation can deliver for patient care”

The chair of Sheffield City Council’s health committee has accused opposition councillors of engaging in a “scaremongering campaign” over proposals to consolidate the city’s ambulance stations into one site.

Councillor Ruth Milsom made the claims ahead of Thursday’s (July 9) Health and Scrutiny Sub-Committee meeting, where the panel will discuss proposals that would see the creation of a new ambulance station in Attercliffe.

If approved, it would also see the closure of three existing ambulance stations, which act as operational bases where staff begin and end shifts, as well as take rest breaks.

Councillor Ruth Milsom, head of the Health Scrutiny Sub-Committee, has accused the Liberal Democrats of engaging in a "scaremongering campaign" over plans to consolidate Sheffield's ambulance stationsplaceholder image
Councillor Ruth Milsom, head of the Health Scrutiny Sub-Committee, has accused the Liberal Democrats of engaging in a "scaremongering campaign" over plans to consolidate Sheffield's ambulance stations | Submit

In June, the Liberal Democrats launched a petition opposing the proposals, claiming it could cause “significantly longer waits” while calling for a public consultation.

However, Yorkshire Ambulance Service responded by explaining how staff only start their shifts at these stations, before being deployed to ‘stand-by points’ where they respond to emergency calls.

They also claimed that other services across the country use single, modernised stations and it has not affected response times.

Coun Milsom said: “I have spoken to ambulance crews as well as Yorkshire Ambulance Service and heard about the need for a new modern service and what consolidation can deliver for patient care.

“Crews have told me that the location of a station is almost irrelevant because they do not operate from there once their shift has started; what is important is the locations of the stand-by points. Conversely, what we have seen from ambulance services across the country are that consolidation results in multiple benefits.”

It is understood that the Lib Dems’ petition has acquired more than 2,000 signatures, with the opposition party pointing out how the station in Attercliffe will be more than 11 miles away from places like Dore and Totley.

However, coun Milsom - who chairs the scrutiny committee - described the petition as “ill-informed,” saying the Lib Dems should have aired their concerns during the meeting with all the details provided.

“The Lib Dems have engaged in classic misinformation with their petition and have criticised the proposals in an ill-informed way,” she added

“They haven’t spoken to Yorkshire Ambulance Service and they haven’t looked at the improvements for patient care that this kind of change has delivered across the country. Instead, they decided to launch a scaremongering campaign against a change that should improve service provision.

“Starting the petition like this is coming at the issue from the wrong angle. Coun Crossthorn has a seat on the health scrutiny committee and can very easily raise her questions there.

“She has made an assumption about the plans and what the outcomes will be for patients, and has gone about telling the public that this proposed change is a danger to their health – despite all evidence to the contrary. That’s just downright irresponsible in my view.

“Obviously we are going to ask all the pertinent questions at scrutiny to ensure that there is absolutely no negative effect on ambulance services, but the funding won’t be released without concrete assurances of faster response times, and metrics of other services that operate this model seem to be showing improvements to response times and to staff facilities.

“Staff are saying this is a good thing, and that’s the angle I’ll be approaching it from at scrutiny.”

Coun Sophie Crossthorn, who launched the petition, responded to the critique, adding: “Given this petition is about ensuring patient voices are heard through a proper public consultation, one which YAS said they would do at a previous committee meeting, I am perplexed by coun Milsom’s comments.

Councillor Sophie Crossthorn launched a petition calling for a public consultation over plans to consolidate all ambulance stations into one facility in Attercliffeplaceholder image
Councillor Sophie Crossthorn launched a petition calling for a public consultation over plans to consolidate all ambulance stations into one facility in Attercliffe | Submit

“I’m certainly not against changing facilities when they are no longer fit for purpose, I am for making sure people feel heard and reassured. Especially for people living in the west of the city, plans to move the ambulance stations up to 11 miles away is something that would cause alarm.

“People have asked me questions, such as what about when paramedics change their shifts, or go on break, or the service is busy, or if there will be standby points. YAS themselves certainly are best placed to answer those questions so that misinformation does not spread.

“I want to see YAS come out and speak to local people, reassure them that this change won’t lead to longer wait times, and bring people with them throughout these changes.”

Labour also provided a statement from Chris, who has worked for the ambulance service for 24 years.

In it, he writes: “YAS have long been amongst the leaders in the NHS ambulance service for innovation and clinical leadership, but we're currently hamstrung by crumbling and outdated estates.

“I understand members of the public having concerns over response times if they live in areas closer to our current stations. The truth is, we're rarely responding from these stations now, unless it's the beginning of the shift or we've returned for our break.

“Our leadership team will be the best people to discuss these issues with, but from our point of view, this move is highly unlikely to increase response times.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice