Row over Sheffield Green Party’s candidate selection for Sheffield Central
The Green Party’s now-suspended former candidate for the Sheffield Central constituency is “devastated” after a new name was put forward to try and become the area’s next MP.
Sheffield Green Party has announced that in Sheffield Central they are sending Cllr Angela Argenzio (Broomhill and Sharrow Vale), the chair of the council’s adult health and social care policy committee as well as the health and wellbeing board.


However, Alison Teal, a former councillor for the Nether Edge and Sharrow ward and a tree campaigner in Sheffield, was selected as the group’s candidate for the Sheffield Central constituency in September 2022 – before being suspended for her views on trans rights soon after.
According to the Yorkshire Post, a complaint against Ms Teal highlighted a series of tweets she had made about transgender issues in recent years, where she said sex is a biological characteristic which doesn’t change over time.
She denied that she was transphobic to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS).
She added: “All I’ve been saying is that it’s really complicated, we need to talk about it. But that itself was seen as transphobic but it’s nonsense.”
Ms Teal said she started her (no-fault) suspension by being the Green Party’s candidate in Sheffield Central and she thought they could not have taken that away from her – but only a few days ago the Green Party announced a new candidate.
She said: “They just held me under this position, waiting for a general election to be called, and now there’s been a general election called, they’re able to use a bureaucratic device to say because I’m suspended, because the suspension hasn’t been resolved, they’re able to select a new candidate – which is what they did.”
She argued that under the party’s policy, she should have been deselected first.
Ms Teal said she was “devastated” and claimed she has done everything the party wanted her to do and participated in the disciplinary process.
She reiterated her claim that she wasn’t transphobic but she argued for a society-wide discussion around, for example, who can use what space.
“These are complex issues”, Ms Teal added.
She also argued that she should be allowed to say what her opinions are so people could challenge her and discuss them.
Ms Teal added: “I’m just absolutely exasperated by this attitude that they can just dispose of me because I have an opinion that a handful of people don’t like.”
When she was asked whether she has thought about quitting the party over the last 19 months (since she has been suspended), Ms Teal said she has been in the party for more than 10 years and while she thought the party was now “corrupted” by a group of people, the majority of the members were “really really good people”.
The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) approached the Sheffield Green Party for a comment.
Cllr Douglas Johnson, the leader of the Green Party in Sheffield, said: “As Alison Teal remains suspended from the Green Party, she is not eligible to stand as a candidate.
“The suspension is handled nationally and the local party has had no involvement with the process.
“Sheffield Green Party had to use emergency selection procedures to have a candidate in place by the deadline.
“I am delighted Angela Argenzio was selected. She is a well-known, credible councillor for Broomhill and Sharrow Vale ward and is a leading member of Sheffield City Council. She has a wide range of experiences both as a teacher and working in the voluntary sector.
“She will make an excellent MP.”
According to the party’s website, Cllr Argenzio is a former teacher and is currently working for City of Sanctuary Sheffield where she used to be a trustee for six years.