Exclusive:Row as controversial Sheffield road scheme approved behind closed doors despite massive local opposition

Plans agreed despite over 100 objections

Sheffield Council officers are making a controversial one way system permanent - despite major opposition by residents.

The move has sparked criticism from senior Sheffield Councillors who say the move should not have been made behind closed doors by unelected officers when there was so much public opposition.

Over 100 objections were received over changes to Nothumberland Road. Photo: Iconic Mediaplaceholder image
Over 100 objections were received over changes to Nothumberland Road. Photo: Iconic Media | Iconic Media

Officials signed off plans which have made a chunk of Northumberland Road, near Weston Park Hospital, one way.

It attracted 107 objections from the public. Only 22 people expressed support in the consultation after an experimental traffic order had been put in place.

The decision, made by the interim assistant director for city transport, to approve this against so much public opposition has been condemned by some councillors.

Councillor Martin Smith, the leader of the Sheffield Council Lib Dems said: “An experimental Road Traffic Order generating this amount of negative feedback should have been referred back to the TRC Committee for a final decision.

“It’s vital that the Council listens to local residents. After all, that’s who we work for.”

Picture shows Northumberland Road at the start of the controversial experimental traffic order. Photo: Iconic Mediaplaceholder image
Picture shows Northumberland Road at the start of the controversial experimental traffic order. Photo: Iconic Media | Iconic Media

And Labour’s Coun Minesh Parekh, the Labour group spokesperson for the Transport, Regeneration and Climate Policy Committee, has also raised concerns.

He said: "The council has recently moved to more officer-delegated decisions. The process should mean that where a decision might be controversial, there will still be political oversight. Even if the decision turns out to be a correct one, with the balance of objections to supportive comments this Experimental Traffic Order received this should have been a councillor decision.

"Considering the experience of Experimental Traffic Orders in my own ward, I do have broader concerns about their use. I would support all 'experimental' decisions having political oversight at a committee level, and will be raise this at the next Transport Committee meeting."

The controversial scheme created a cycle lane along half of the the road, and removed some parking spaces.

It follows the construction of a Sheffield University building near the site.

Locals had raised concerns that the move to block traffic from Witham Road from entering Northumberland Road. They had raised concerns that channeling more traffic into Broomhill would create a danger.

Council officers dismissed the concerns and said that they did not believe this had happened.

Officers said in a report that after the council gave Sheffield University planning permission for its new building, a revised highway layout was been introduced on Northumberland Road that was intended to bring in measures to improve accessibility for cyclists and pedestrians through an Experimental Traffic Order (ETO), which allowed the measures to be implemented on a trial basis and the impact monitored prior to any decision on permanent adoption.

The report stated: “According to traffic flow data collected during the experimental period there has been some minor reallocation of motorised traffic on roads adjacent to Northumberland Road but not at a level to cause concern.

“The scheme has been subject to statutory consultation and monitoring throughout the experimental period. In total, 107 objections and 27 expressions of support have been received. A considerable proportion of objections were submitted at the initial stages of implementation or prior to the scheme becoming fully operational. Correspondence in the latter stages of the experimental period has been limited, with very few representations received in the last 10 months.

“Having regard to the monitoring evidence, the objectives of the scheme, and the statutory duties of the Council, the measures are considered to be operating satisfactorily and delivering the intended outcomes in relation to active travel provision and traffic management within the corridor. On balance, it is considered that the benefits of the scheme outweigh the unwithdrawn objections received.”

Sheffield Green Party group leader, Coun Angela Argenzio, who is also ward councillor for Broomhill and Sharrow Vale, said the three ward councillors thought the scheme has some positives, including improving cycle safety for one, but residents were concerned about the number of university buildings going up in the area.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice