Rotherham Council’s landlord licensing policy faces challenge over ‘flawed’ consultation

A Rotherham Council scheme that requires landlords in parts of the borough to apply for licences has been called in for review, with councillors claiming the public consultation behind it was “flawed and misleading.”

The selective licensing scheme, approved by cabinet on 20 October, is designed to tackle poor-quality housing and anti-social behaviour by forcing landlords in certain areas to meet set standards. Licences cost £975 per property over five years.

The policy will cover parts of Eastwood, East Dene, Clifton, Masbrough, Kimberworth, Thurcroft, Dinnington, Brinsworth, Parkgate and the town centre, replacing the previous scheme introduced in 2020.

But independent councillor Taiba Yasseen has formally called in the decision, saying residents and landlords were not properly consulted. Her call-in was supported by Liberal Democrat councillors Adam Carter, Charlotte Carter and Drew Tarmey.

The selective licensing scheme, approved by cabinet on 20 October, is designed to tackle poor-quality housing and anti-social behaviour by forcing landlords in certain areas to meet set standards.placeholder image
The selective licensing scheme, approved by cabinet on 20 October, is designed to tackle poor-quality housing and anti-social behaviour by forcing landlords in certain areas to meet set standards.

In their notice, the councillors argue that maps and leaflets used in the consultation mislabelled neighbourhoods, leaving people unsure whether their properties were affected. They also say the council’s switch in wording from “Selective Licensing” to “Landlord Licensing” confused the public about what the scheme actually covers.

The councillors claim the consultation excluded some residents who do not use digital services and failed to publish key documents such as draft area plans.

They also question whether the evidence used to justify the scheme meets the legal requirements. The call-in says some of the data used to show “high migration” in parts of Rotherham does not meet national guidance.

Concerns were also raised about the council’s equality assessment, which the councillors say did not properly consider the impact on ethnic minority or disabled tenants. They warn that the scheme could lead to higher rents for vulnerable tenants if landlords pass on the cost of licensing fees.

The call-in also questions why some areas, including Boston Castle and Clifton, were included in the new scheme, despite what councillors describe as limited evidence of housing problems there.

Because of the call-in, the decision will now be reviewed by the council’s Overview and Scrutiny Management Board on 12 November. The board will decide whether the cabinet should look at the issue again or allow the decision to stand.

A Rotherham Council report said the authority had followed all required procedures and would present its evidence to the scrutiny board.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice