Reform and Labour councillors clash as questions over green belt housing raised in Sheffield council meeting

The council leader offered to visit potential greenbelt housing sites

The leader of Sheffield’s Reform councillors was told to “sit down” as questions around green belt developments became heated at a town hall meeting.

Fans placed at either side of Sheffield’s council chamber were not enough to lower the temperature during the full council meeting on Wednesday (June 24), as campaigners’ questions over the controversial local plan ended up with elected officials clashing.

Greenbelt campaigners raised a number of questions for newly-appointed council leader Fran Belbin, related to school and religious provisions in new housing plans, and a lack of housing density in the city centre.

Reform's John Hesketh shouted "shameful" at council leader Fran Belbin as she answered questions about greenbelt housingplaceholder image
Reform's John Hesketh shouted "shameful" at council leader Fran Belbin as she answered questions about greenbelt housing | Sheffield City Council

In response, coun Belbin explained how a lot of these decisions are currently being handled by the planning inspectorate, separate to the council, however assured that depending on their decisions further public consultation will take place.

She added: “60 per cent of new homes will be built in the city centre.”

Written answers available online and provided to those in attendance, reveal that funding for schools has not yet been procured, adding: “The belonging team will work with the Department for Education if the Sheffield Plan is adopted and if ongoing monitoring of pupil numbers confirms that a need exists.

“On the second part of the question, the inspectors conclude that ‘the council’s assessment work to date shows that both sites could potentially be suitable for an element of burial use/schools provision’.”

Coun Belbin offered to visit Handsworth - where 1,738 new homes have been proposed - to which campaigners responded: “We will be sending you an email.”

However, when follow-up questions were offered to the public gallery, the council’s Reform contingent began heckling the council leader.

One person in the public gallery asked for a ‘yes or no’ answer to whether development would start before funding was acquired for schools, while others said that most people would be able to point out undeveloped brownfield sites that could be used for housing.

Sheffield Reform councillors leader John Hesketh shouted out “just answer the question,” as coun Belbin was talking, while Park and Arbourthorne councillor Matt Smith said “it was a yes or no question.”

Coun Belbin explained how to be approved for housing, brownfield sites have to be “suitable, available and developable” which many do not meet.

She went on to say: “Not all brownfield sites pass these tests, and some development opportunities simply don’t exist now but will come forward at some point in the future.”

John Hesketh shouted out “shameful” and “answer the question properly.”

Lord Mayor Andrew Sangar asked the Reform leader to stop interrupting, when he stood up to explain his position.

“Councillor Hesketh, sit down,” the Lord Mayor responded.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice