OPINION: Amey's pledge to take Sheffield's roads from 'worst in the country to the best' was a sales tactic
Amey's promise in 2012 to take Sheffield's roads from "the worst in the country to the best" was either grossly optimistic, a sales tactic, or just silly.
Roads are like pockets - no one remarks on their quality until they have holes in them. And all I ever hear about Sheffield's roads is all the holes they have.


On March 14, I published an examination of Sheffield’s Streets Ahead contract, the 25-year agreement for council contractor Amey to manage all roads and fix all potholes until 2037. Over 13 years and £1bn into the deal, I wanted to see if Sheffield was getting its money’s worth.
"Sheffield will go from having the worst roads in the UK to having the best roads in the UK," announced Mike Notman, Director of Highways PFI at Amey in July 2012.
Blimey. £2bn can fill a lot of holes, but was that ever going to happen? Did no one in public relations tell Mr Notman to take it down a notch?
While researching this story, I hoped I’d find a smoking gun for why the topic of potholes has boiled over in 2026. Some quirk of Sheffield's weather or some problem with how the city's highways were originally constructed, or some insight that Amey's materials are unfit for the job.
Nothing so satisfying, unfortunately. I think the reason the topic of the month in March 2026 is potholes is because it rained all winter long and the repair teams are now in arrears. No sooner are potholes filled than new ones emerge.
Sheffield Council figures show that the number of potholes, and pothole repairs, have tripled in recent years, and utterly boiling over in 2024/25.
Estimate number of Category 1 (severe, dangerous) potholes filled:
| 2020/21 | 2021/22 | 2022/23 | 2023/24 | 2024/25 |
| 2,348 | 2,707 | 2,862 | 5,762 | 6,179 |
Estimate number of Category 2 (not dangerous) potholes filled:
| 2020/21 | 2021/22 | 2022/23 | 2023/24 | 2024/25 |
| 2,448 | 1,539 | 1,650 | 1,586 | 5,770 |
It’s not just Sheffield on that one. An annual study (sadly published days after my story) revealed the cost of fixing all the roads in England and Wales would today top £18bn.
I also found frustration with both the council and the contractors everywhere.
Motorists associate Amey’s repairs with “black gravel in a hole,” deriding it as cheap. What they are seeing is the temporary cold lay asphalt repair. In theory, these are meant to enjoy a permanent repair within a month.
But, wherever they go, drivers only spot “black gravel on roads”, and conclude it is the only repair Amey is interested in. No one spoke to me about permanent repairs, because they drive over them without noticing.
Besides, every driver can name a noticeable-but-not-outright dangerous pothole they know that hasn’t been fixed in months. There’s one on Campo Lane that goes right down to the cobblestone beneath I realised was pictured by The Star nearly six months ago.
Combine all this with the unfathomable idea of a 25-year-long, £2.2bn contract (only a percentage of which is spent on roads) that the public can't even read in its entirety, and Sheffield's taxpayers begin to wonder if they're being taken for a ride.
If the extra repair teams don't work fast enough, the public will want its money back.
