It's up to Reform to prove voting for party was not a mistake, Barnsley Lib Dem chair says

"I think [Reform] are going to be quite disappointed when they find out how hard local government is”

There was little surprise on Friday, May 8 when Reform secured a majority in the Barnsley local election.

Speaking during what was a third recount at the time for the Penistone West ward, Hannah Kitching, chair of the Liberal Democrats in Barnsley, said: "I think whatever your political affiliation, we have a situation in Barnsley where we've gone from having a council administration with a huge amount of experience and knowledge, to a council administration with no experience, but that is democracy.

Barnsley Liberal Democrat chair Hannah Kitching has said Reform now needs to prove to voters in Barnsley that it 'wasn't a mistake' to put them in charge.placeholder image
Barnsley Liberal Democrat chair Hannah Kitching has said Reform now needs to prove to voters in Barnsley that it 'wasn't a mistake' to put them in charge. | LDRS

"The people of Barnsley have cast their votes, and elected a Reform majority council, and it is up to them now to prove to the public that wasn't a mistake."

Labour had previously been in control of the Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council since its creation in 1974. With the Labour Party holding several decades of experience in local government, the Liberal Democrat chair says Reform’s inexperience may mean they are in for a shock.

"I think [Reform] are going to be quite disappointed when they find out how hard local government is," she said.

“It was really hard to see in any of their campaign material any sort of particular policies or ambitions other than make services better but not raising council tax. If you know anything about local government you know that’s completely impossible.”

Speaking on Reform’s campaigning in Barnsley, she reflected on their leaflets used to reach voters and present their policies.

“Cutting waste on the council [for example]. As an opposition councillor, I might’ve not always agreed with the decisions that the Labour council has made about how they spend the public’s money, and we’re on record as disagreeing with not all but a good number of those decisions.”

She said that contrary to popular belief, ‘there is very little waste in local government because there simply is just not enough money to waste any of it’.

Ms Kitching - who did not stand in the most recent election but still serves on Penistone Town Council - said that for Liberal Democrats in Barnsley, their priorities had not been changed by the election outcome.

“I think given the lack of local government experience that is now going to be in charge of Barnsley Council, that opposition and scrutiny is going to be needed more than ever,” she added.

“We’ve been the opposition on Barnsley council since I was elected really in 2018. We were an effective opposition when there was only one of us, we were an effective opposition when there were 12 of us, so we’ve never had the numbers against the majority party but we’ve made a difference.

"We’ve got the experience and skills to scrutinise, to challenge, to hold the administration of the council to account.”

Hannah Kitching hugged Florentine Bootha-King, who secured her seat in Penistone West after three recounts.placeholder image
Hannah Kitching hugged Florentine Bootha-King, who secured her seat in Penistone West after three recounts. | Iconic Media

After Labour suffered many defeats to Reform candidates across the borough, the Liberal Democrats are now the second biggest party in Barnsley Council, meaning they will act as the opposition.

“It has been a bad night for the Labour Party, I think it is fair to say. It’s also been a very bad night for the Green Party who have made absolutely no headway whatsoever in Barnsley,” Ms Kitching added.

“While we have not come out of it completely unscathed we feel like we have weathered it better than [other parties] have.”

The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) contacted current Barnsley Reform branch chair Edward Dillingham for comment.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice