Dinnington children’s home staffing plans approved despite residents’ concerns
Plans to increase staffing levels at a children’s home in Dinnington have been approved by councillors, despite objections over traffic and parking.
Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council’s planning board agreed to amend conditions at a property on Swinston Hill Road, which was granted permission last year to operate as a home for up to three children.


The changes will allow three staff members to be on duty at one time, instead of two, with an additional staff member present when required.
The applicant said the revised staffing arrangements followed discussions with Ofsted and were needed to meet safeguarding requirements.
The application attracted 24 objections, with residents warning the increase in staff could lead to more vehicles and congestion on the residential street.
Some said the changes would “completely change the dynamic” of the original scheme, while others raised concerns about road safety near a nearby junction.
Dinnington St John’s Town Council also objected, questioning whether the property is large enough to accommodate the level of staffing and visiting professionals associated with the home.
Ms. A. Wright, speaking behalf of Dinnington St John’s Town Council, said : “This is a quiet family focused street. Residents include elderly people, families with young children, and long standing homeowners who have built their lives there. The siting of a 24 hour care facility, however small in scale, brings with it continuous staff movements, visits from professionals and relatives, and a level of operational intensity that only increase with the number of children in residents there.
“The assumption that all staff will arrive and leave neatly within shift times is unrealistic, and visitor parking will inevitably spill onto the street. This raises avoidable safety issues, especially with school children regularly walking along this route.”
Mr. G. Tabor, objecting, told the meeting that shingle on the home’s drive is ‘causing a slip hazard’.
Mr Tabor added: “The increase in staff will increase traffic generation, creating a real danger to those road users. It will without a doubt, affect the amenities of vocal residents who seem to have been ignored.
Mrs. K. Tabor, also objecting, added: ”Even with four vehicles on the driveway, it’s impossible for any of them, apart from the one blocking the entrance to leave without or enter without maneuvering the other vehicles first. It’s an accident waiting to happen.
“If there are five parking spaces at the front….and off street parking in the front of the house, why does the applicant’s wife often park in front of our property? This is because there’s insufficient parking at the property. Imagine the chaos, if this planning is granted, and I reiterate, all for financial gain.”
However, Verity Thurtle, director of Braveheart care and the home’s manager, told the meeting that the area’s police had visited the property and raised no concerns about the home or its location, describing feedback as positive and confirming crime was not concentrated in the immediate area.
“Although the property itself is large, with six double bedrooms, we have made a very deliberate decision to limit occupancy to just three children,” added Ms Thurtle.
“This ensures that each child receives high levels of care, attention and support in a stable environment.
“The property has a private driveway that can accommodate up to five vehicles. This is more than sufficient for staff and visiting professionals and we do not anticipate any impact on local parking.
“We recognize that some concerns raised by the community are rooted in long standing stigma around Children’s Homes. Historically, they’ve been sometimes labeled as places for problem children. But in reality, this is very different. All we’re trying to do is give three vulnerable young people a good start in life.”
Planning officers told the meeting the increase in staffing would result in only a modest rise in vehicle movements, mainly during daytime hours.
They said activity at the site would remain comparable to that of a large family home.
Highways officers raised no objections, stating that Swinston Hill Road can accommodate some on-street parking and that the widened driveway at the property can hold up to five vehicles.
The application also included a change to parking conditions, removing the requirement for marked bays due to the gravel surface.
The proposed care home manager said the changes were necessary to ensure children placed at the home are properly supported.
A report to councillors stated the home would still accommodate a maximum of three children, with the revised rota spreading staff across a 24-hour period rather than increasing occupancy.
Councillors voted to approve the application subject to updated conditions.
