Sheffield street tree protester challenges council over latest apologies

A Sheffield tree protester has challenged the council’s claim that it is making “strong progress” following the latest investigation into the street tree felling scandal.

Martin Pickles, who faced an injunction for his part in street tree protests, has rejected an apology from the council. He says councillors may have the wrong impression that the situation is now resolved.

Members of Sheffield City Council watch on screens as chair of the independent inquiry into the city street trees scandal, Sir Mark Lowcock, addresses an extraordinary council meeting in 2023 to discuss the report's findingsplaceholder image
Members of Sheffield City Council watch on screens as chair of the independent inquiry into the city street trees scandal, Sir Mark Lowcock, addresses an extraordinary council meeting in 2023 to discuss the report's findings

Law firm VWV was commissioned by Sheffield City Council in December 2023 to make an independent inquiry into outstanding complaints made by four street tree protesters who were threatened with court injunctions by Sheffield City Council.

In total, 13 people considered “main protagonists” by the council had to give undertakings to halt their protests against the felling of thousands of street trees, or face court action.

Chief executive of Sheffield City Council, Kate Josephs, at Sheffield Town Hall.placeholder image
Chief executive of Sheffield City Council, Kate Josephs, at Sheffield Town Hall.

The four lodged complaints in 2021 following questions they asked the council. VWV said that the council made little response, other than to decide the complaints would be dealt with by Sir Mark Lowcock’s inquiry into the street tree scandal.

Critical

Sir Mark’s report was heavily critical of the council’s actions and demanded widespread changes that had huge repercussions.

However, the Lowcock inquiry team said that the four complaints lay outside the scope of what they were investigating.

The VWV report concluded the council must “issue full and complete apologies” to each of the complainants from the chief executive of the council, on top of those ordered by Lowcock.

VWV published a report with eight recommendations for action which was accepted by finance and performance policy committee in July 2025.

It said the council must “consider how to demonstrate, in an open and transparent way, acceptance, compliance and accountability of these recommendations”.

Challenge

It concluded that legal staff must be “the voice of constructive challenge and role models of good governance” when action was considered.

The committee this week (February 25) received a six-month progress report.

It said: “This six-month update reports strong progress against the recommendations arising from the VWV external investigation into complaints related to the street trees campaign.

“Most actions have now been completed or embedded within ongoing programmes, with the remaining items on track for delivery.

“The update reflects wider improvements implemented through the Future Sheffield Programme and strengthened accountability through performance frameworks.”

Transformation

Future Sheffield is a three-year programme for “improvement, development and transformation” of council services.

Mr Pickles appeared at the meeting to voice his objections. He said he had rejected the council’s apology.

“The update for recommendation eight in the action plan shows the apologies have been delivered,” he told councillors. “This may give the impression all the complaints have been settled.

“In the interests of transparency, please could the finance and policy committee document how many of the complainants’ apologies have been accepted or are unresolved.”

Chair Coun Mike Levery responded: “Of the four complaints, two have agreed and been issued with apologies based on the findings in the report.

“We believe that that a third person does not wish to pursue an apology based on the findings.

“In your case, as you are aware an apology was agreed and issued last year. You have subsequently rescinded acceptance of that apology and have helpfully explained your reasons for doing so.”

He said that the council head of legal services, general counsel David Hollis, would respond to him this week.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice