Sheffield Green councillors say Labour were “political point scoring” over council fallout
“We will always speak truth to power. And that's a threat to the establishment parties”
Sheffield Green Councillors Angela Argenzio and Alexi Dimond said Labour’s demands were “an attempt of national party to control what local parties do” and share their side of the fallout of the city council administration.


After weeks of negotiations between councillors to save Sheffield's Labour/Green leadership following the Prime Minister's demands for local Green groups to denounce their party's 'Zionism is Racism' motion, council leader Fran Belbin announced on 11 November that the joint administration "must now come to an end."
Coun Belbin told the LDRS that continuing to lead the council in collaboration with the Sheffield Green Group was “not on the table” after a Green councillor's historic “antisemitic” social media posts were revealed by the Jewish Chronicle.
However, leader of the Green group on Sheffield City Council, Angela Argenzio rejected the claim from Fran Belbin that the surfacing of the posts led to the joint administration ending.
She said: “It broke down before this even arose, so that's just a complete distraction.
“It might have galvanised support with the members, the way that was presented. But actually, it's got nothing to do with the breakdown of the talks, because that had already happened.”
Both Green councillors told the LDRS the “goalposts moved several times” which they found confusing.
Councillor Alexi Dimond explained that before full council on 4 November, the parties were having “really constructive discussions, we established that we wanted to continue working together.”
Coun Dimond said councillors had agreed on a joint statement and "were about to press send" when Coun Belbin knocked on the door five minutes before full council began and said she hadn’t got sign-off from Labour’s National Executive Committee (NEC).


Coun Dimond said a refreshed joint statement that came after, approved by the NEC was “back to square one” in its messaging.
“It feels that there wasn't good faith on the other side,” Coun Argenzio said.
Coun Dimond said: “It's like they wasted our time pretending there was something to negotiate and there wasn't, there were these lines that we had to agree to."
He said: “We’re happy to clarify certain things, but we're not prepared to do their demand, which is to throw our national party and our decision making processes under the bus.
“If another party poses a policy that Andy Burnham and the NEC doesn't agree with, then they're gonna scupper any local power sharing arrangements.
“Asking everyone to submit to the Labour whip is not a way that you can operate.”
Coun Argenzio added: “This is the thing that we fundamentally disagree. For us, it's about local democracy.”


Coun Argenzio now believes: “It’s all about next year's election.”
“I think that Fran understood how badly looked locally, what they were trying to do.
“I think they thought they could gain some kind of political points on this by taking a supposedly moral high ground on something that is irrelevant to most people in Sheffield i.e. a Green Party national policy position.”
Councillor Dimond said the Jewish Chronicle's story on Councillor Mustafa Ahmed was “not a coincidence.”
He said: “These are historic comments they’ve been sitting on.”
Coun Argenzio added: “I'm fairly certain it is a deliberate thing to have come at this time.”


She said the national Green Party were currently doing an investigation leaving local Greens “waiting to hear.”
Coun Argenzio said: “It's been really, really difficult in Burngreave,” since Coun Ahmed was elected in May.
“There is huge support for Mustafa locally. You just have to go for a walk with him and people come out of shops and things and it's incredible. He's incredibly hard-working, passionate, community minded. He is there for everybody, regardless of their faith, their race, their culture.
“I think Labour have taken it as a huge offence that, what they perceive as their God-given right to hold that part of the city. Especially losing to us. But they really have lost those areas.
“There has been quite a lot of racial slurs, attacks, threats. It's not been easy for Coun Ahmed. But he's been kind of really strong through [his time as a councillor]."
Coun Belbin told the LDRS Sheffield’s minority Jewish community felt there had been “no real attempt” to listen to them on the Greens' motion.
“That is false,” Coun Argenzio said. She said she’d heard from Jewish Green Party members and a prominent member of the Jewish community.
The Green councillors said they don’t know exactly how things are going to pan out now.


Coun Dimond said: “We do want to continue being part of the administration, helping to deliver for the people of Sheffield.”
“But that doesn't mean that we're going to get Labour bullying us,” Coun Argenzio added.
They say Greens won the biggest vote share in Sheffield in May, so have "the biggest mandate to be in the administration from the last election."
Coun Dimond believes the other parties on Sheffield Council have disagreed with “the strong position that Greens have consistently held against the genocide.”
He said: “We will always speak truth to power. And that's a threat to the establishment parties.”
During the council fallout, Coun Argenzio went on a planned trip to Nablus in the West Bank.
While she hadn't felt able to fully reflect yet, she said: “The journey has confirmed my conviction that what the Israeli government is doing, not just in Gaza, but in Israel itself, and in the West Bank, the Palestinian territories, is against international law.”