Sheffield doctor questions NHS involvement with company “allegedly complicit in human rights abuses”

A Sheffield doctor has questioned how a key NHS contract was awarded to a company that he said has been linked to human rights abuses.

Resident doctor and Medact Sheffield healthworkers’ campaign member Rory Gibson raised the issue at a meeting of Sheffield City Council’s health scrutiny sub-committee (December 18).

Coun Laura McClean, who chairs Sheffield City Council's health scrutiny sub-committee. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Coun Laura McClean, who chairs Sheffield City Council's health scrutiny sub-committee. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

He said that a £330m national NHS contract to provide a federated data platform was awarded to the company Palantir Technologies “by fairly untransparent means”.

He said that locally the data platform (FDP) plays a key role in the South Yorkshire NHS integrated care board’s data and insight strategy.

Coun Toby Mallinson speaking at a meeting of Sheffield City Council's health scrutiny sub-committee, December 18, 2025. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Coun Toby Mallinson speaking at a meeting of Sheffield City Council's health scrutiny sub-committee, December 18, 2025. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

“Palantir has been criticised by the UN and Amnesty International for allegedly likely being complicit in human rights abuses, including the genocide in Gaza, and oppressive surveillance in the US and Europe.

“Palantir’s involvement in the FDP threatens patient data privacy and the deepening of health inequities, patient trust in health data systems and the ongoing privatisation and asset-stripping of the NHS.

Ethical

“The BMA [British Medical Association] opposes the rollout of the FDP due to Palantir’s involvement. Its adoption is not mandated by NHS England.

“How does the committee intend to evaluate the ethical considerations of inclusion of the FDP within local health data policy and does the committee oppose the FDP rollout in South Yorkshire considering the aforementioned information?”

Committee chair Coun Laura McClean said there hadn’t been time to provide Dr Gibson with a full, considered response at the meeting and she would do so on behalf of the committee in writing.

Coun Ruth Milsom said that Dr Gibson was asking members of the committee for their thoughts, rather than asking the integrated care board.

Coun McClean replied that she would be asking questions of the board before giving a response from the committee.

Coun Toby Mallinson said: “I do think that this committee can take a view on the question of ethical procurement. I think we can make a political statement about it.

“I think it’s a crucial issue. The sale of the data system to Palantir to run it is a really worrying move. I fully support the questioner’s thrust.

“Local health trusts really have to consider very carefully if they do want to go down that route. We should articulate that as well.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice