Sheffield councillor labels Budget Day a “mess” for government in economic crisis debate

A Sheffield councillor has decried the “mess” surrounding the Budget including leaks and government U-turns and called for more support for smaller businesses plus an improved relationship with the EU.

LibDem group leader Coun Martin Smith made the comments when he proposed a motion, which was seconded by Coun Mike Levery, at Sheffield City Council’s full meeting on Wednesday (December 3).

Coun Martin Smith, leader of the LibDems on Sheffield City Council. Picture: Sheffield LibDemsplaceholder image
Coun Martin Smith, leader of the LibDems on Sheffield City Council. Picture: Sheffield LibDems

The motion argued that “the government is failing to create conditions for sustainable and long-term economic growth”.

It noted that the UK gross domestic product (GDP) growth was 0.1% in July to September and unemployment levels are currently at 5%, their highest in four years.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who was criticised by LibDems on Sheffield City Council over her 2025 autumn Budget. Picture: UK Parliamentplaceholder image
Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who was criticised by LibDems on Sheffield City Council over her 2025 autumn Budget. Picture: UK Parliament

It said that the increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions continue to negatively impact businesses across Sheffield and that “high-profile U-turns and uncertainty ahead of the Budget have negatively affected investment into the UK economy and the mood of households”.

The motion called for Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves to cut VAT by 5% for hospitality businesses to boost the high street, paid for by a windfall tax on big banks.

U-turns

It also argued that “the government should prioritise fixing our relationship with the European Union and fairly taxing social media companies”.

Coun Ibby Ullah, pictured in the Sheffield council chamber in August 2025. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Coun Ibby Ullah, pictured in the Sheffield council chamber in August 2025. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

The motion stated that the council should ask Sheffield MPs to support the Liberal Democrat Ten Minute Rule Bill on creating a new customs union with the EU. It also wanted a copy of the motion to go to the Chancellor.

Coun Smith said: “What a mess on Budget Day. Leaks, broken promises, massive U-turns, a plan for the highest level of personal taxation in decades and absolutely nothing to address the fractured trading relationship with our closest neighbours in Europe.”

He said that small and medium-sized businesses, which employ more than half of the city’s working age population, are struggling, meaning that young people have been particularly badly hit by government financial policy.

Coun Smith that the levy imposed on international students will cause further financial problems for the city’s universities, costing them £10m a year.

Sheffield City Council Green Party Coun Alexi Dimond. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Sheffield City Council Green Party Coun Alexi Dimond. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

He said that, instead of a plan for growth, the Chancellor delivered a “low-growth, high-tax Budget from a government that isn’t listening”.

Stagnation

LibDems Coun Richard Shaw and Mohammed Mahroof put forward an amendment which added more detail about the effects of the Budget. It welcomed lifting the two-child benefit cap but said this should have happened sooner.

Coun Ibby Ullah proposed a Labour amendment, seconded by Coun Minesh Parekh. It said “the government inherited an economy weakened by 14 years of growth and wage stagnation, low productivity, slashed public services, rising NHS waiting lists, and record-high debt interest costing almost £1 in every £10 of taxpayers’ money”.

It added that “despite this difficult context, the government is fixing the foundations of the country through fair choices to support working people and restore economic stability”.

The amendment welcomed a £150 cut in energy bills from April 2026, a freeze in rail fares for the first time in 30 years, and frozen prescription charges.

Increases in the national minimum wage and national living wage would benefit 2.7 million low-paid workers. It also pointed to “the scrapping of the two-child benefits cap, lifting 450,000 children out of poverty, and the state pension increase of £575” as well as changes affecting owners of property worth more than £2m.

Champions

Coun Ullah said: “We will always speak up for Sheffield because this city deserves champions, not cynics.” He said the council is investing in skills, jobs and industries of the future to create long-term growth, in partnership with the government and South Yorkshire Mayor.

“Can things be better? Absolutely. We cannot ignore the context – this government is rebuilding after 14 years of coalition and Tory decline, years of low growth, low wages and cuts to services and record NHS waiting lists.

“Despite that, Labour is fixing the foundations and putting the country first.”

Coun Ullah argued that Sheffield’s economy is growing and diversifying.

Coun Parekh offered solidarity to workers at both universities who have been taking strike action. He said that Hallam University have cut hundreds of jobs and are preparing to cut hundreds more while continuing to expand the campus and spending money on a centre in London.

Lockout

He said the University of Sheffield are threatening a staff lockout and “trying to force through cuts they don’t need to make” while sitting on millions in cash reserves.

Coun Parekh said it was “despicable” to watch LibDem peers vote with Tories in the House of Lords to weaken the Employment Rights Act.

He said: “Frankly, I am surprised that you had the gall to come here and pretend that your party has anything of value to say about how to run an economy.”

The Green Party amendment was proposed by Coun Alexi Dimond and seconded by Coun Peter Gilbert. It regretted that the government has “abandoned its promise to give all workers the right to claim dismissal from day one” and that it “lacked the courage to significantly reform council tax or extreme wealth in the Budget”.

The amendment called for wealth taxes and a increase on tax for big corporations.

It urged politicians “to move beyond GDP obsession and instead measure human development, societal wellbeing and environmental health”.

Rampant

The amendment also called for the UK to rejoin the EU and to reverse privatisation in the NHS and monopoly services such as water, energy, rail and buses.

Coun Dimond said the original motion put forward no local actions. “This motion doesn’t address or even identify the deeper causes of economic crisis or crises.

“It does not affect rampant and widening inequality and the fact that wealth of the top 50 richest families in the UK now exceeds the wealth of the poorest half of the population.”

He said it does not address the sell-off since 1979 of council homes, water, services and energy companies, that “GDP is a terrible measure of the health of a nation” and does not address climate change, which causes food, conflicts insecurity and disasters.

Coun Gilbert said the country, “one of the richest in the world to the tune of $18 trillion”, is facing inequality and environmental crises, not an economic one.

Emergency

“Our wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few. Our wealth is concentrated in the south. Our wealth is concentrated with those who do not want this situation to change.”

He said that a Westminster briefing last week on the climate and nature emergency was told “it is now too late for non-radical futures.

“One in four homes, around eight million UK homes, are at risk of flooding by 2050. Food security will be precarious.

“These are just some of the critical threats our economy faces. So, I say we have a leadership crisis.”

Coun Gilbert said that tying policy into GDP in late-stage capitalism is “Gross Dereliction of Purpose”.

Coun Elle Dodd asked why Green peers voted with LibDems on part of the Employment Rights Act.

Napoleonic

She also criticised Green councillor Maroof Raouf’s call at the meeting for Sheffield to have the country’s biggest Christmas tree next year, saying that taxpayers’ money should be spent on supporting the poorest families instead.

Coun John Booker said: “People voted to leave the Napoleonic protection racket called the EU.”

The Labour amendment was carried 65-1 but voting in parts meant that the paragraph about “fixing the foundations of the country” was lost.

The Green amendment was lost 16-52 and the LibDem amendment was carried 38-30. The substantive motion as amended was carried 38-30.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice