Pub refused permission to open at 8am ahead of Sheffield United V Sheffield Wednesday derby
A Sheffield pub has been refused permission to open early on the day of the Steel City derby because of the fear of violent disorder in the city.
The Beer Engine on Cemetery Road in Highfield was refused a temporary event notice to open from 8am on Sunday, November 10, the date of the first derby between the city’s rival teams for five-and-a-half years. The match kicks off at 12.30pm at Bramall Lane.
A meeting of Sheffield City Council’s licensing sub-committee on October 21 heard from South Yorkshire Police that they had decided against a “more draconian” blanket ban on pubs opening but had decided to oppose all applications for temporary event notices. They give venues permission to open outside their normal hours on a one-off basis.
Pub landlord Thomas Harrington said he intended opening to serve breakfast and drinks to Sheffield United fans who usually visit before matches. He said it was unfair because a nearby pub that has a licence allowing it to open from 9am will be allowed to serve customers.


Carl Fender, counsel for the police, said there is a long history of violence associated with derby matches, including a mass brawl in 2013 and an attack on a Sheffield Wednesday fan in 2022 that ended in a manslaughter conviction. He added: “This match is effectively an incendiary to what would be the reignition of long-standing rivalries between fans of both of these clubs.”
He said that originally the match was scheduled for the Friday evening but the police had held “very difficult negotiations” with the Football League, both clubs and Sky TV to get it moved. This was because fans would be able to start drinking after work.
Draconian
Det Sgt John Armitage of the police football intelligence unit said: “There were considerations around a more draconian request but actually it’s just for people to operate within the licences they’ve got so that we can mitigate the amount of alcohol consumption and hopefully associated violence and disorder.”
Mr Fender said that the rescheduled date also coincides with Remembrance Sunday, when many people will be at the commemoration in Barkers Pool.
Coun Karen McGowan said: “I’m really disappointed that this is happening on Remembrance Sunday.”
Coun McGowan also asked if there had been any previous problems at the premises on match days. Det Sgt Armitage said there are no particular issues with the venue.
He said the dangers of violence around Friday night matches are greatest and the policing bill will already be £250,000, so the aim was to have an early kick-off to help mitigate against that risk.
Det Sgt Armitage said that the scheduling of fixtures is out of police hands.
“The options available to us sadly are dictated by the EFL (English Football League), football clubs and Sky TV.”
Chief Insp Gareth Thomas also said that police resources would be extremely stretched on the day and the force is bringing in reinforcements from around the country.
Mr Harrington said that times are tough in the licensed trade and he saw a chance to make extra money for the business and also to provide a service for fans who visit regularly. He offered to open later, have door staff and only allow in Blades fans with season tickets or match tickets.
Promoting the opening on social media would be a “red rag to a bull”, he recognised, and he offered only to tell established football fan customers.
Mr Harrington said the pub is well known for welcoming away fans who are well behaved, including ex-Norwich City director and TV cook Delia Smith ordering tapas on one occasion. He said that as a craft beer pub, the Beer Engine does not attract trouble-makers.