Council and campaigners reveal new strategy to protect Sheffield's street trees following felling controversy

Campaigners, authorities and other stakeholders have produced a new strategy to protect Sheffield street trees for generations to come, after a controversial saga lasting more than four years.

It follows nine months of work between Sheffield Tree Action Group, Sheffield Council, Amey, experts from Natural Capital Solutions, Leeds Council and the Woodland Trust – which has been chaired by Liz Ballard, chief executive of Sheffield and Rotherham Wildlife Trust.

Paul Selby, from STAG, said: “Assuming the strategy is adopted and implemented by the council, residents can be confident their street trees will be protected, sustained, and increased in number.”

Collaboration on the plans started after years of rows between STAG, the council and Amey over a £2.2 billion highways management contract called Streets Ahead.

Police at one of Sheffield's tree felling sites. placeholder image
Police at one of Sheffield's tree felling sites. | jpress

During that time 5,400 trees were felled - about 600 of which the Forestry Commission said were chopped illegally. There were also mass protests, arrests and court cases.

A pause in felling, mediated talks and meetings have allowed them to finally agree a way forward.

Coun Mark Jones, council cabinet member for environment and streetscene, admitted the authority made wrong decisions in the past, but was now looking to lead on the issue.

He said: “Trees matter. Not only do they help improve air quality and support wildlife, but they have also been proven to benefit our mental health.

Police supported a pre-dawn tree-felling operation on Rustlings Road last year placeholder image
Police supported a pre-dawn tree-felling operation on Rustlings Road last year | jpress

“We need better and more robust measures in place to make sure trees across Sheffield continue providing value to our natural and urban environment.

“We’ve not always got the approach to street trees right. However, through the hard work and dedication of the development group and others we have created this new strategy, one which ensures we listen carefully to all viewpoints and will shape how we do things better.”

Plans focus around six key goals: Sustainably and carefully manage street trees in accordance with best practice; Ensure street trees are more resilient through the type and age of trees we plant and how we manage current stock; Increase the value and benefits of street trees; Contribute to a more equal distribution of urban forest across the city to promote health and wellbeing; Increase street tree canopy cover; and Involve the wider community in caring for an valuing street trees.

Consultation on the strategy will begin soon and run until spring 2021, while the group will also seek commitment to the strategy from other stakeholders.

Police at one of Sheffield's tree felling sites. placeholder image
Police at one of Sheffield's tree felling sites. | jpress

After that is completed, a finalised plan will be produced and implemented.

Part of the work included commissioning Treeconomics to report on the benefits of Sheffield's 35,629 street trees.

It found the current value of street tree benefits in the city was £7.7 million over 80 years and the public amenity value over the same time period was £340m.

It also found the street trees remove three tonnes of air pollutants every year and store 12,000 tonnes of carbon.

Tree felling in Sheffield placeholder image
Tree felling in Sheffield | jpress

Going forwards, each tree will be assessed by a six-stage process and any street tree needing replacing because it is either dead, dying, diseased, damaged or dangerous will be replaced on a one-for-one basis close to the original site.

More than 20 war memorial trees on Western Road were due to be felled and replaced (Marie Caley)placeholder image
More than 20 war memorial trees on Western Road were due to be felled and replaced (Marie Caley) | JPIMedia
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice