Call for more action to tackle “daily misery” of anti-social behaviour for Sheffield residents
Sheffield councillors have called for more effective action to tackle anti-social behaviour in city communities including making it easier for victims to get help.
The issue was discussed at the full monthly meeting of Sheffield City Council (December 3).


A motion was proposed by deputy council leader Coun Fran Belbin and seconded by her Labour Party colleague Coun Karen McGowan.
It said that the council “believes every resident in Sheffield should be able to feel safe and secure in their home and community, but too many have their lives blighted by anti-social behaviour (ASB)”.


The motion outlined that ASB takes many forms, including intimidating behaviour, harassment, vehicle nuisance, drug dealing, excessive noise, vandalism and graffiti.
It often increases when it is linked to criminal or sexual exploitation such as ‘cuckooing’, where criminals effectively take over someone’s home.
Afraid
It said the council believes that such behaviours leave people feeling afraid, intimidated and unsafe in their homes.


The motion welcomed government investment of £200 million to recruit 3,000 extra neighbourhood police officers and Police Community Support Officers.
It noted the introduction of the Crime and Policing Bill which would give police powers to make on-the-spot seizures of off-road bikes, e-scooters and cars involved in ASB and introduce new Respect Orders enabling courts to ban adult offenders from specified activities and locations.
The motion stressed the need for early intervention that stops problems becoming entrenched.
While recognising 14 years of cuts to services have diminished resources during rising demand, the motion said “residents need clear pathways to report ASB, not a system where cases bounce between teams or stall without resolution”.
Fighting
This includes being able to provide photographic, video and sound evidence of ASB as well as verbal or written statements, via multiple methods including an online portal.
Coun Belbin said: “These are residents in communal blocks of flats who are living through the daily misery of noise, shouting, fighting and swearing coming through their walls, intimidating dogs in their communal areas that make them afraid to leave their flats, homes where drug dealing and sex work are taking place day and night so that neighbours are left feeling unsafe because their communal doors are being propped open or having their locks smashed off and where vehicles are constantly coming and going.
“Where sometimes they are coming across broken glass, drug paraphernalia and even faeces on the stairs.”
She said that too often the council does not act quickly enough, so problems continue or escalate. “We ask tenants to fill in paper diary sheets and then appear to take no action.
“We leave tenants unclear who they should report issues to – is it the police, is it neighbourhood officers, is it anti-social behaviour officers?” She said that if a situation improves but then deteriorates again, tenants must start the whole process again.
Cuckooing
Coun Belbin said that the council must switch up its approach, work better across departments and liaise effectively with the police and voluntary sector.
She said that where vulnerable people are being targeted for cuckooing, they must get support to deal with issues including mental health problems and addictions that leave them open to exploitation.
“We need staff with the time, the training and the skills to do this and we must empower our tenants to report more easily. It shouldn’t be hard to submit video evidence in this day and age.”
Coun McGowan said that an issue in her ward with young people taking drugs and causing ASB at Base Green shops and in the hallways of nearby flats had taken 18 months to deal with. She said that Community Actions Groups (CAGs) had been a great help.
A LibDem amendment moved by Coun Ian Horner and seconded by Coun Tim Huggan said that “persistent shoplifting by organised groups leaves local people, including shop workers, feeling more vulnerable in their neighbourhoods”.
Deterrent
It added that widespread sales of illegal tobacco and vapes on the high street represent a significant organised crime problem and that the current enforcement regime is not a sufficient deterrent.
The amendment called for the government to grant local authorities further powers to close down premises selling illegal tobacco.
Coun Horner said that low-paid shop and hospitality workers are among those affected. Shop staff face violence and abuse in dealing with shoplifters.
He said he was appalled that new Green leader Zack Polanski said on TV that shoplifters are victims as well.
“I do not accept that that. There are organised gangs here, there are people doing this – we need to speak out for the victims of anti-social behaviour across this chamber loudly and clearly.”
‘Prats’
Coun Horner said that drivers causing a nuisance by having car meets at Drakehouse Retail Park are not victims but “prats”.
A Green Party amendment was moved by Coun Maleiki Haybe and seconded by Coun Brian Holmshaw. It argued that “long-term community safety comes from tackling inequality through secure housing, strong youth and mental health services and action on poverty, and believes enforcement alone cannot address the causes of ASB and that the Government’s investment of £200m for policing could instead strengthen these root cause interventions.”
The amendment said that many people involved in ASB, especially young people, “are themselves vulnerable and often affected by trauma, exploitation or exclusion, and believes that responses must prioritise early intervention as well as prevention and community-led support”. Enforcement activity should be “proportionate, trauma informed and culturally competent”.
Misconduct
The amendment pointed to the recent Panorama TV prgramme on police on police misconduct an abuse as underlining the need for transparency and accountability in all enforcement activity.
Coun Haybe said that he agreed with Coun Horner that police must take frm action but the issues would never be resolved without looking at root causes.
He said the city centre PSPO, which was set up to deal with ASB by creating an exclusion zone, isn’t working. “It’s just pushed people from one street to a poorer street. That’s displacement, not safety.”
He said that community-led action, treating people with compassion and understanding, had been highlighted to the council as an effective way forward that was not reflected in the motion.
Coun Haybe said that young black men are more likely to be stopped and searched by police and the Panorama programme gave great cause for concern about the effect of more policing, rather than dealing with social issues.
The LibDem motion was passed by a vote of 37-1-30 and the Green amendment was accepted by a vote of 37-31 but two paragraphs fell. This included an assertion that £200m extra police funding would be better spent on tackling root causes.
The substantive motion, as amended, was passed unanimously.