Council rejects call to waive garden waste fees after months of disruption
Rotherham Council has rejected a call to waive next year’s garden waste collection fees, following a heated debate over months of disruption to the service.
Rotherham Council’s decision not to waive next year’s garden waste collection fee, after a motion to compensate residents for months of disruption was voted down at Wednesday’s full council meeting.
The proposal, tabled by Conservative councillors Simon Ball and Joshua Bacon, called for the council to waive the 2026 garden waste subscription fee, issue a public apology, and commission an independent review into the service.
It followed widespread frustration among residents whose brown bin collections were suspended in early August due to staff shortages, with the disruption continuing well beyond the council’s planned end-of-August restart date.


Subscribers were instead offered a £10 refund or discount on next year’s renewal, a gesture described by the motion as “inadequate and insulting.”
During the debate, Cllr Ball said: “Labour’s mismanagement isn’t just sloppy, it’s callous. Spare a thought to the non drivers in our borough, they can’t just chuck the lot in the boat and XX to the tip like the council seems to assume.
“Call outs for garden fires have increased significantly as frustrated residents resort to burning their accumulated waste, putting unnecessary strain on our already overstretched fire service. This Labour failure isn’t just about the bins, it’s creating knock on dangers, risking lives and resources that should be focused elsewhere.”
The motion argued that the suspension “disproportionately affected vulnerable groups,” including disabled residents who rely on the brown bin service for accessible waste disposal.
The standard annual subscription fee for garden waste collection in Rotherham is £49 for the first bin and £40 for each additional bin, meaning many households have paid significantly more than the refund being offered.
Labour councillor Victoria Cusworth branded the motion ‘disproportionate to the level of disruption experienced’.
“Yes, there have been service challenges, and yes, we must acknowledge and learn from them. The financial implications of this motion are considerable. Implementing it would divert vital resources away from other areas.
“I can’t think of any other service that I pay for where I would lose a few weeks service and get a full year’s refund.”
The motion was lost following a vote.
