Coroner highlights NHS communication concerns after son killed parents in Sheffield

A coroner has told the NHS she fears future deaths could happen unless it takes action after investigating a son who stabbed his parents to death during a psychotic episode.

Tanyka Rawden, a senior coroner for the South Yorkshire area (West), concluded an inquest into the death of Bryan and Mary Andrews and following her investigation she also sent a prevention of future deaths report to Sheffield Health and Social Care NHS Foundation Trust.

A coroner has told the NHS she fears future deaths could happen unless it takes action after investigating a son who stabbed his parents to death during a psychotic episode.placeholder image
A coroner has told the NHS she fears future deaths could happen unless it takes action after investigating a son who stabbed his parents to death during a psychotic episode.

She did so because, in her opinion, the NHS needs to take action to prevent future deaths, highlighting her concerns about a lack of communication between different NHS services.

In her report, Ms Rawden said Mr and Mrs Andrews were unlawfully killed and the medical cause of death was “multiple stab wounds”.

The report said that they had died on November 27, 2022, at their home address after being stabbed by their adult son. The report said he had epilepsy caused by an area of abnormal brain development in the right frontal lobe.

He continued to have regular seizures despite the medication he was taking. The report also added that he had a documented history of postictal psychosis.

Ms Rawden said in her report to the NHS: “His mental health had deteriorated significantly in the two years before his parents died.

“Seven months before his parents died, he reported thoughts of wanting to kill someone.

“In a police interview, he admitted to killing his parents and attempting to end his own life by inflicting a knife wound in his abdomen.

“He pleaded guilty to murder on the grounds of diminished responsibility and was sentenced to an indefinite hospital order.”

Among her matters of concern was the lack of communication between services about the relationship between the diagnosis of epilepsy and the psychotic symptoms experienced by the person responsible for the deaths.

The coroner wrote: “This led to significant time lapses in treatment and rejection of referrals.”

The report said that on November 18, 2020, an “urgent referral was made to the Single Point of Access Team by his general practitioner, concerned about his prolonged suicidal ideation”. However, he was referred back to the GP by the team to refer him to the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies Service.

Two days later the GP referred him again to the Single Point of Access Team to liaise with the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies Service.

Ms Rawden found that the two teams had communicated with each other and the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies Service did not have a programme specific to epilepsy.

The report said: “A referral to the Neurology Therapy Service was made and it was decided a request to the general practitioner for the mental health nurse in the surgery to offer an assessment was appropriate. The surgery was not informed of this.”

A month later, in December 2020, the Single Point of Access Team received a referral from a consultant neurologist requesting a medication review as his anxiety levels were affecting his epilepsy treatment.

However, as the GP was reviewing his medication, the review “wasn’t required”. The neurologist had not been notified of this, the report said.

On April 29, 2022, the man called the Single Point of Access Team to tell them he was having a serious psychotic episode and thought he was going to kill someone.

Ms Rawden found that he had decided to attend the emergency department where he had been assessed by the Liaison Psychiatry Team after which he had been referred to the Home Treatment Team – without informing his consultant neurologist.

A few days later a trial of anti-psychotic medication was discussed at a medical review. However, “the required consultant review of whether to prescribe anti-psychotic medication with his epilepsy medication was not carried out”.

Ms Rawden added that on May 4, 2022, a referral to the Early Intervention Service was rejected for not meeting the criteria for first episode psychosis – despite having clean evidence of psychosis in the assessment by the Liaison Psychiatry Team on April 29, 2022, and in subsequent contacts with the Home Treatment Team. ,

The coroner wrote: “On May 5, 2022, a first referral was made to the Emotional Wellbeing Service via email asking for their input into his care.

“The email was sent to an address not manned daily.

“When a response was provided it was unclear whether a new treatment episode had been opened.”

A few days later, he had been discharged from the Home Treatment Team but a discharge summary was not sent to his GP.

On October 4, 2022, the report added that “a referral was sent to the Single Point of Access Team by his General Practitioner that he was presenting as paranoid and delusional with suicidal ideation”.

The report ended: “A screen for urgency found this was a routine referral. The referral was triaged on November 22, 2022 when he was invited to contact the Single Point of Access Team for a further discussion.”

Sheffield Health and Social Care NHS Foundation Trust will have until November 29, 2024, to respond to this report.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice