Conservative councillor questions ‘waste’ in universal baby pack scheme
A Conservative councillor has raised questions about Rotherham’s universal baby pack scheme, describing it as “laudable” but querying whether providing packs to all families represents the best use of public money.
The scheme, which sees Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council provide free baby packs to all new parents in the borough, has seen high take-up since its launch, prompting the council to consider extending it.


The proposals were examined by councillors this week as part of routine scrutiny of the council’s health and early years services.
If the scheme is extended, it would be backed by a budget of £410,000 a year for the next four years – a total of £1.6m.
Each pack contains clothing, a toy, a book and other practical items designed to support babies during their first six months.
Conservative councillor John Blackham, who represents Anston & Woodsetts, told a meeting of the council’s overview and scrutiny committee meeting today (Feb 3) that the scheme was “laudable” but questioned whether providing the packs universally was the best use of public money, suggesting a more targeted approach could reduce waste while maintaining quality.
Cllr Blackham questioned if the funding would be better used to target the borough’s most needy families instead.
“Anybody will take one for free, and a lot of parents in Rotherham will not need one in reality,” he told the meeting.
” I don’t like that this isn’t targeted because I believe we’re wasting a lot of money. I certainly don’t see an advantage for that amount of money.
” I think what you’re trying to do is laudable, but I do think it’s this particular aspect of it basically includes a substantial amount of waste.”
Labour councillors defended the universal approach, saying it ensures families do not miss out on support.
Councillor Victoria Cuswroth, cabinet member for children and young people said the scheme is ‘absolutely not a waste of money,’ and that the authority is ‘committed to give every child the best start in life’.
“It’s not always about finance, it’s about preparedness for having a baby.”
Cllr Cusworth added that the items and information included in the packs help families engage with Family Hubs and other services, while also ensuring important messages, such as safe sleeping, reach every new parent in Rotherham.
“When you look at safe sleeping overlay, which does result in the death of babies, then to get sort of messages like that out along with useful items and more information, I don’t think that a penny of that’s wasted.”
The council has previously said the scheme forms part of its wider work to support early years development and reduce inequalities across the borough.
