Campaigners urge council break 15-month silence over gripes to huge loss of Sheffield green land

Branding the silence a “damage to trust” the pressure group has likened it to the lip service public engagement exposed by the Lowcock Report into Sheffield’s street tree-felling scandal

Campaigners are urging Sheffield Council’s leader to publicly address issues raised over housing plans spelling Sheffield’s biggest loss of green belt land ever.

In a open letter to Councillor Fran Belbin, Sheffield Green Belt Alliance (SGBA) claims members are still waiting for answers to a "long list” of questions put to the council’s planning department “470 days ago”.

Campaigners at ‘Hands Off S35 Greenbelt’ protest march in June 2025placeholder image
Campaigners at ‘Hands Off S35 Greenbelt’ protest march in June 2025 | Hands Off S35 Greenbelt

Branding the silence a “damage to trust” the pressure group has likened it to the lip service public engagement exposed by the Lowcock Report into Sheffield’s street tree-felling scandal.

The letter comes following Councillor Belbin’s visit this month to parcels of green land set aside in S35, S13 and S12 to accommodate 3,529 houses as part of Sheffield’s local housing plan.

SGBA writes: “We thank you for coming. Since the 14 sites were announced in April 2025 it is the first time a leader of this council has stood on the land with us.

“The Star reports that you left with a long list of questions for the planning team. We hope you get answers from them - we have been putting our questions and concerns to the team for over 470 days.”

Campaigners go on to reel off a list of occasions during which concerns have been batted away.

Clive Betts MP (Sheffield South East), say the activists, told planning inspectors that officers “declined to attend public meetings in S12 and S13”.

They added: “Written questions sent afterwards came back as ‘we really haven't got time to deal with these, sorry’.

“At full council in February 2026 your predecessor told the chamber senior council officers have advised questions of detail about the local plan should be dealt with through the examination process.

“That answer was then given to four public questions in succession. Councillor Martin Smith called it a complete U-turn on previous commitments and reminded the chamber that Lowcock found a lack of openness had eroded public trust.

“You left our sites with a list of questions for the planning team - publish your questions, the replies and the advice behind them.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice