From a futuristic monorail shuttling passengers above The Moor, to indoor ski slopes and a new shopping centre, these proposals for major projects all eventually fell by the wayside.
Are there any you wish had materialised, or is Sheffield better off without them?

9. Sheffield Tower
This building would have become Sheffield's tallest - in this case rising to 37 storeys on Sheaf Street, where it would have soared above visitors arriving at Sheffield station - had it ever been constructed. Sheffield Tower, as it was called to keep things simple, was proposed by Sheffield Hallam University in 2018 and would have featured a five-star hotel, 200 flats, restaurants and a conference hall. But the university said in 2020 that it had tested the market and the proposed tower had not proved viable in the way it envisaged. Photo: Sheffield Hallam University

10. Giant football beside the M1
Proposals for a 5.5-metre diameter steel football beside the M1 near Meadowhall, which would stand nearly 8m tall including the plinth, got the go-ahead in 2010. It was conceived by Sheffield FC, the world's oldest football club, to promote two of the city's greatest exports - the beautiful game and stainless steel. Plans for the sculpture were dealt a blow when the land off Shepcote Lane, in Tinsley, where it was to be located, was sold by the steel firm Outukumpu. They were revived four years ago as part of the Sheffield Home of Football campaign to better market the city's proud sporting heritage, but have since disappeared without trace again. Photo: HR Media

11. Sevenstone shopping centre
It was truly the end of an era when John Lewis announced it was closing its Sheffield store at Barker's Pool, which was previously home to Cole Brothers, in 2021. Who knows what might have happened had plans to create a new retail quarter anchored by a bigger John Lewis shop, on the site of the Wellington Street fire station between Carver Street and Rockingham Street, ever become a reality. That new shopping complex, dubbbed Sevenstone, was first mooted in the mid-90s and an outline planning application was approved in 2006 but the recession then hit and the plans were eventually abandoned, with John Lewis deciding back then to stay put. Photo: Hammerson UK Properties Plc

12. Four-star hotel opposite Sheffield station
A four-star hotel with 200 bedrooms was planned opposite Sheffield station, on the site of Sheffield Hallam University's old Nelson Mandela Building, on Pond Street. A planning application for the development, which would also have included offices, restaurants and cafes, along with a basement car park, actually got the green light back in 2007 but construction never started. Photo: CTP St. James/Aedas Architects Ltd

