No compensation for 79-year-old woman injured after falling over paving slab in Sheffield city centre
Minion Green has complained to Amey after tripping up on a city centre paving slab.
A Sheffield pensioner says she feels “shaken up and disappointed” after sustaining injuries to her lip, neck and head after tripping up on a city centre paving slab.
Minion Green, from Bradway, was walking down Norfolk Row towards Marks & Spencers when she suddenly tripped just yards away from St Marie’s Cathedral.
She told the Star: “I fell so hard on my face that I bounced. I couldn’t even pick myself up and needed help from a chap who came over and helped me to stand up.
“I was very shocked, my lip was cut and bleeding, my head hurt and I had a massive bump. Both sides of my neck were in a lot of pain as well. I looked around and there was a slab stone that was at least two inches out of place, it was loose and had water underneath.
“And I thought that it shouldn't be left like that because there were no cones around it or anything.”


Minion explained that her first thought was to report the incident in an attempt to prevent others from suffering serious injuries.
“I got the bus back home as I was too shaken up,” Minion explained.


“I tried ringing council highways. They sent me a form to fill in but they sent it to my email address. I’m not too familiar with using emails so I got a paper copy and sent out my complaint.”
Minion says she received no compensation from Sheffield Council’s roads maintenance contractor, Amey, after the incident, with the company informing her that work to repair the issue had already started before her fall.
The letter she received from Amey’s claim handling agent reads: “Please be advised that the repairs were carried out within that period and it is unfortunate that your incident occurred in the intervening period.
“This being so, we consider that our client has not been in breach of their statutory duties and moreover that they have taken reasonable care in the circumstances to ensure the safety of the highway.
“Whilst we have every sympathy with you, we regret we are unable to offer any compensation on this occasion. We remind you of your rights to seek independent legal advice.”
Minion expressed disappointment at the way in which her claim was handled, adding that there should have been some sign or cone to signify that the area was unsafe to walk on.
She added: “I had a headache for four days after my fall. I continued recovery at home. It was about a week until I stopped feeling shaken up and the pains started to ease.”
Amey was also contacted by The Star.
- RELATED: 'Man stamped on ex-girlfriend's head in row over what she was wearing'
- RELATED: Sheffield weather forecast after Storm Boelo battered the city
- RELATED: Train disruption as Storm Boelo damages rail network
- RELATED: Council "shirking responsibility" over historic swimming pool, claim campaigners
