14 of Sheffield's 'roughest' pubs according to readers, including 1 where landlord 'hid upstairs' during fight

A good pub is the heartbeat of its community, and Sheffield boasts many fine watering holes where that is the case.

But it’s fair to say that some of the city’s boozers in days gone by had a less savoury reputation.

There’s a lot of debate about which pubs in Sheffield were the city’s roughest, where only the hardiest souls would dare to show their faces.

For every pub which people recall being particularly rough back in the day, there are always people who were once regulars there and will say its reputation was undeserved.

We’ve put together a list of some of Sheffield ‘roughest’ pubs, based on our readers’ suggestions, but we’re included the memories of those who have leapt to the defence of those establishments and recalled happy days spent drinking there.

At one of the pubs on our list, the landlord reportedly resorted to hiding upstairs when fighting broke out below, while others were supposedly frequented by shoplifters who would sell their wares to fellow punters.

But for each story about violence and criminality, there are those who remember a ‘buzzing’ place full of ‘genuine folk’, or, as one person put it, a ‘proper pub’.

Is your old local on our list, and do you think it deserves to be there, or is there another pub you think should be included in our rundown of Sheffield’s roughest pubs from years gone by?

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice