Meadowhall is one of the most popular shopping centres and has been a firm favourite with shoppers since its launch 35 years ago.

But though many love it, like everything, there’s always room for improvement. Star readers have been sharing what they feel Meadowhall is lacking - and the responses paint a picture of both deep nostalgia and a desire for more practical, everyday convenience.

When asked what shoppers would most like to see return or arrive at the centre, the suggestions ranged from major department stores to long-lost icons many still remember fondly.

But it was the mention of the Disney Store that truly struck a chord.

When Julia Roe said she wanted “The Disney Shop back,” the comment received more than 200 likes, suggesting a wave of people still feel a strong attachment to the much-missed family favourite.

The Disney Store in Meadowhall is set to close

The call for a supermarket also appeared repeatedly throughout the responses.

Chris Jones said a large food store would allow shoppers to “do your clothes shop, get some dinner then grab the weekly shop all in one,” explaining that he misses the “massive Sainsbury’s” that once occupied the site and believes another supermarket chain should be willing to take its place.

Broader retail wishes came from commenters like Dale Evers, who said Meadowhall could use a supermarket, The Range, a Christmas shop and even a bridal boutique, while several others repeatedly pushed for Home Bargains to make an appearance.

Bershka is opening on Thursday December 12. The Spanish firm has taken the huge unit, previously Zara, between the Apple store and Omega watch shop on Upper High Street. Its three core collections, Bershka, BSK and Man, will be available, offering a range from casual wear to sports and from basic garments to 'statement fashion pieces'.

Many were keen to see specific brands or retail categories introduced.

Nicola Hall called for a B&M store, while Charleen Loveday said she would welcome a dedicated home and interiors retailer.

Homeware suggestions included stores such as Zara Home, H&M Home.

A return of large department stores was another popular suggestion.

Corey Beech said Meadowhall could benefit from the presence of “a proper department store like John Lewis, Debenhams or a Selfridges,” adding that even an extension of the existing Lego Shop would be welcomed by many.

Jacqui Garner listed everything from Savers and Home Bargains to a market, a supermarket and even the return of Burger King, arguing that having everything in one location would make life easier for families and those travelling in from further afield.

Seasonal traditions also made an appearance.

Emily Olivia asked for the Christmas bears to be restored to their original house - prompting a passionate “yessssss” from fellow shopper Tariq Wright, reflecting the affection still held for Meadowhall’s festive displays of the past.

Some readers also suggested opportunities for improved safety and convenience.

Lara Jean Louise Couldwell said she would support the introduction of X-ray scanners to improve security.

Laura Holmes proposed locker facilities for shoppers using public transport, an idea Craig Wilson praised as “fantastic”, saying it would save shoppers from having to carry heavy bags around all day.

One comment stood out for the vivid memory it evoked.

Kerry Beard called for the return of the Rock Island Diner and shared a story of attending a Grease-themed night there as a teenager, when a waiter serenaded her with Sandy before ending the evening with a photo of him kneeling at her side.

She remembered sitting on the iconic car outside with the dancing waiters, capturing a moment many readers said reminded them of Meadowhall’s old atmosphere.

Others took a more humorous angle.

Peter Clarke suggested a “husband/partner drop-off centre” equipped with a bar and gaming area, a proposal that quickly gained support from those tired of dragging reluctant shoppers around the centre.

Food-based ideas included everything from a pie and mash café, suggested emphatically by Marie Paris Humayun, to calls for Cinnabon, Chipotle.

Ziad Hmeidan said he would simply like to see healthier food options available, a sentiment that was quickly built on by Aisha Ahmed, who noted that such choices should come at a price that doesn’t “cost an arm and a leg.”

Their exchange reflected a broader undercurrent of shoppers wanting more affordable, varied dining.

Fitness enthusiasts were vocal too, with Joy Wilson and Ben Firth both calling for Gymshark, and Rudo Cheche adding Lululemon to the wishlist.

And finally, some urged Meadowhall to think beyond retail altogether.

Stephanie Hannam-Swain said she hoped the centre might consider more innovative additions, such as a Citizens Advice Bureau or other support services that could make Meadowhall more than just a shopping destination.