'People need to vote smartly if we are going to keep Reform out of our city' - Reader's letter
Jacob Harris
Sheffield's Greens had a good local election result. But their claims to be the party best placed to stand up to Reform in our city frankly don't stack up.


They gained six seats in May's local elections. Four of them were in Labour held ward, two of them were from the Liberal Democrats.
So what we can say is that they did very well against other progressive parties.
But in every single seat which Reform gained, they came third or worse. In Stocksbridge and Upper Don, the only seat Reform held before the election, they got just 9.3%
The Greens were simply not competitive in any Reform-facing ward in Sheffield and to say that they are the party to challenge Reform is for the birds.
In many wards —such as Park & Arborthourne, where Labour's Nabeela Mowlana was replaced by a Reform councillor—votes that splintered off to the Greens actually gave Reform the seat.
The decapitation campaigns the Greens waged, particularly to unseat council leader Tom Hunt in Walkley by fewer than 75 votes, likely cost Labour much more time and resources to defend which they could have used against Reform.
The same applies for Liberal Democrats having to defend Graves Park and Ecclesall from Green threats making them less well equipped to protect their seats in Beighton and Mosborough.
On the other side of the Pennines there’s going to a by-election in the Makerfield constituency where yet again the Greens are planning to split the progressive vote in an attempt to keep Andy Burnham out of Parliament.
Two newly elected Reform councillors have now gone independent, in Woodhouse and Shiregreen. Labour came second in both of these seats and have sitting councillors already working for their communities there.
If a by-election arises, they are best placed to keep them out.
People need to vote smartly if we are going to keep Reform out of our city and we must not let Green cynicism get in the way of actually stopping Reform.
