'What does it mean to be a Sheffielder?' From cockle men to fishcakes - does any of it still matter?

What makes a Sheffielder?

What is the definition of being a Sheffielder?

Do the steelworks still matter to younger generations?placeholder image
Do the steelworks still matter to younger generations?

Who amongst us knows what the ingredients are to be able to proudly carry the title of being a true Sheffield person?

I was wondering the other day if it was about eating cockles served from a basket at room temperature in a pub crowded with people who share your accent?

The rather strange question came up following a discussion in the office about meat which is protected by security tags. Stick with me and I'll try to explain my Steel City logic.

I am staggered by the amount of products that have to have electronic markers to stop shoplifters at my local Co-op.

Considering I don't shop there very often, I should actually have been more surprised at the amount of times I have seen staff try and stop people walking out with their pockets full and no money handed over.

It is a sad indictment of society in 2026.

The official opening of the Castle Square (Hole in the Road) subway on November 27, 1967placeholder image
The official opening of the Castle Square (Hole in the Road) subway on November 27, 1967

It also got me thinking who actually buys meat that has been stuffed in suspicious pockets and then put for sale as if it fell of the back of a lorry?

Food standards ... eat your heart out.

That conversation took us to the wonderful Cockle Man of the past.

When I was a teenager, there was a man who would go around the pubs selling seafood. Pickled mussels or a packet of crisps? How things have changed.

There were Cockle Men all over the city, carrying their wears in baskets and always seeming to manage a roaring trade.

Not everyone in our team could imagine what I was describing let alone had experienced it.

Ha, surely they can't call themselves Sheffielders?

Then I was told there are still plenty of pubs which still stock jars of cockles in vinegar behind the bar.

Oh, so maybe I can't call myself a Shefifelder either because I clearly don't drink in the right pubs.

Fear not, I am self-assured in my belonging. As long as you know what a fishcake is, then you're a Sheffielder, right?

Well, my mind was truly blown by the amount of people in our office who, when put on the spot, described something coated in breadcrumbs!

That was another huge section of Sheffielders wiped out. If a fishcake isn't a small slice of fish between slices of potato and wrapped in batter, you can just forget it.

I didn't dare raise the topic of breadcakes.

It would have broken my heart to have had to dismiss the Sheffield claims of anyone who uttered the words roll, bap or cob.

So what makes a Sheffielder? It isn't a question that is possible to answer.

It certainly isn't about how you look or what labels you use for food. It is very much about shared memories - the Hole in the Road, cockle men and Roxy's for me.

But that is completely different depending on your age - it makes you no more or less a Sheffielder.

Does it matter if you were born here like me or moved here as an adult like my mum 60 years ago? Is she less Sheffield than me or do I win?

Kindness of spirit is a characteristic that all true Sheffielders carry. It matters not if you were born at Nether Edge Hospital, only arrived yesterday or decided to stay after uni in the 1960s.

My mum delivered generations of Sheffielders in that hospital, assuming birth gives us a claim. But she was born in Lancashire herself which wipes out all my ancestorical claims to Yorkshire. Let's not raise the War of the Roses.

We all belong here and it is ours to share. That's what I believe.

What do you think makes a Sheffielder?

What makes your heart leap with joy because it is so unique to us and what are the memories that makes it all so special to you? We love it here, we love to be Sheffielders and we are all quite fond of each other when things are going well.

So back to where we started.

There was somebody during the discussion who pipped up that they didn't think anybody actually related to the Steel City tag any more and it was outdated.

This thought had never crossed my mind and left me feeling more than uneasy.

Yes, generations move on and there is a huge section of the population here who have never known a steelworker or relied on a steel wage but is that proud history really irrelevant already?

What does make a Sheffielder?

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice