"I'm warming to the place Sheffield city centre is right now" - reader's letter
Sheffield resident Tony Abdy Hill reflects on the changing face of Sheffield city centre...
Sheffield city centre is fit for purpose.
I often take my lunch in Sheffield city centre as I am based near The Moor for work.


My walk through town over the last 45 years has seen a lot of changes but broadly I think the city centre is nicer than the 1980's although far quieter than its glory days.
We all know the decision to build Meadowhall probably signed the death knell for new retail growth in open air trading spaces and the ease of car parking at a shopping centre means it really won’t ever come back.
The car is the means to transport shopping, not the bus or bicycle, even hardened proponents use Amazon’s diesel powered vans to get their laptop accessories, yoga mats and dungarees delivered direct to Meersbrook.
Cockaynes, Pauldens, Walshes ,Roberts Brothers, BHS, Woolworths, Banners, Cole Brothers all based their businesses on motorised customers spending and carrying away purchases via nearby parking.
Having no interest in smart phones I can’t even download an online payment app to park these days!
I have to use my bicycle for the centre.
I do think that although it has taken many years of over investment and haphazard planning, the idea of a 21st century city with more residential and light consumer goods shops allied with food and drink has started to pay off.
If we give up on major retail coming back in an Amazon driven world then the slow tilt towards an experience driven city centre is actually a smart move.
I was sat eating my sandwich on Fargate this Friday in warm weather and footfall was indeed good throughout the 40 minutes I was people watching.
The crowds don't tell the story though, what I saw was very few people had shopping bags.
Doesn’t matter how busy it is if they are looking,not spending. No bags, no sales.
This won’t comfort Marks & Spencer or bring back HL Browns but they must have been there for something.
If light bites, niche retail, wine bars and coffees are the reason then we have to embrace a future where they come for an experience wearing clothes they bought online.
Leeds city centre has often been quoted as a better all-round experience with more shops and premium retailers.
But I noticed the same thing there last week, most people were not carrying bags. I may not agree with all the changes particularly bus access in our Town Hall area, a retrograde step but if anyone thinks the old black and white photos of Sheffielders loaded with shopping swarming around Fargate like ants are coming back they are living in the past.
We have a new present and a future we can either work with or work against.
I'm warming to the place Sheffield city centre is right now.
Tony Abdy Hill
S11
