New theatre and museum could open at Victorian church in Sheffield

A cavernous Victorian church in Sheffield could become a new cultural hub, housing a museum, theatre and even a ticket office for a proposed new railway service.

St Matthias Church in Stocksbridge closed last month, with a special farewell service held by the Bishop of Sheffield, the Right Reverend Dr Pete Wilcox, after the size of its congregration dwindled from up to 1,000 during its peak to as few as 15 worshippers.

St Matthias Church in Stocksbridgeplaceholder image
St Matthias Church in Stocksbridge

It was anticipated the building would probably be sold and converted to flats, but proposals have now emerged to preserve it for the community as a visitor attraction.

The church closed last monthplaceholder image
The church closed last month
placeholder image
Read More
Forgotten Sheffield railway line could be revived with steam trains and commuter...

The building could also act as a permanent base for the Steel Valley Beacon Arts theatre group, which until now has had a nomadic existence.

In the long run, it might house a ticket office for the proposed railway service on the existing line between Sheffield Victoria and Stocksbridge.

The stained glass windows at St Matthias Churchplaceholder image
The stained glass windows at St Matthias Church

Dennis Pindar, who chairs the history society, said: "We would support any plans to provide a larger space for the museum to display more of the objects we have, and it would be great to combine that with a new theatre in a cultural takeover.

"If it's converted into apartments it would be lost forever, which would be a great shame given it was built for the people of Stocksbridge."

Chris Bell, of Don Valley Railway, said the church seemed like a natural choice for a ticket office should a new passenger station open at Stocksbridge, given it backs on to the existing line.

The Diocese of Sheffield said church commissioners would now take the lead when it comes to deciding what happens to the building.

"They will look at alternative uses, and a meeting date has been set towards the end of the summer/early autumn," added LJ Buxton, communications manager for the diocese.

St Matthias Church on Manchester Road was built in memory of Samuel Fox, who founded the nearby steelworks, and was consecrated in 1890, three years after his death.

The church has more than 500 seats and is noted for the quality of its stained glass windows.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice