Report into £65m 'black hole' in South Yorkshire Police finances rules out 'misuse of police funds'
Steps are being taken to balance the books
An investigation into a £65m financial black hole at South Yorkshire Police has ruled out “misappropriation or misuse of police funds”.
But it has identified layers of problems in the way the force’s finances were handled and scrutinised from 2018 until the errors were exposed almost two years ago.
By that point, financial commitments had been allowed to snowball unseen, reaching a total discrepancy of £65m.
Problems were identified when control of the county’s policing switched from the old Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner, to South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority.
The Chartered Institute of Public Finances and Accountancy was called in to establish what went wrong and they have now reported back.
Essentially, the force had been borrowing for big projects, without accounting for that in accounts or the impact it would have in future.
They identified mistakes by finance staff, with “flawed assumptions” becoming “embedded in routine practice”.
The then finance team “lacked technical knowledge” relating to the issues, CIPFA found, with those who sat on the Police and Crime Commissioner’s internal audit committee not given specific training “to help members interrogate statutory financial provisions”, the report found.


The Office of Police and Crime Commissioner did use external treasury advisors and they had proposed an external review of how that area of finances was handled - but the suggestion was ignored, even though “visible inconsistencies” were apparent, said the report.
The debacle has put the spotlight on wider accounting practice, with the report’s authors stating: “The case raises a sector-wide question about whether current audit and governance codes of practice are sufficiently attuned to detecting cumulative risks that fall outside the current National Audit Office code of audit practice.”
Since the black-hole was discovered, South Yorkshire Police have been taking steps to make savings needed to rebalance the books.
South Yorkshire’s Deputy Mayor, Kilvinder Vigurs, who is now responsible for oversight of South Yorkshire Police, said: “The issues arose out of accounting and budgetary errors, compounded by weaknesses in financial governance.
“It is important to reiterate that the issues did not arise out of misappropriation or misuse of police funds.
“Our focus is now on the future; supporting South Yorkshire Police to keep people safe, maintaining public confidence in policing, and ensuring policing in our region remains financially sustainable for the long-term.”