Sheffield houses: Controversial 'freehold' solicitor Andrew Milne found guilty of stalking

A London solicitor accused of demanding up to £25,000 from householders in Sheffield has been found guilty of stalking.

Andrew Milne was found guilty after a trial at Stratford Magistrates’ Court on Tuesday, February 10. He will be sentenced on March 10.

Milne is also being investigated by South Yorkshire Police and the Solicitors Regulation Authority over alleged financial demands from leaseholders in Sheffield.

Sheffieldplaceholder image
Sheffield | Chris Lawton

Raising the issue in the House of Commons, Sheffield MP Olivia Blake said he bought the freeholds to more than 170 houses in Sheffield at auction.

He then sent letters to householders claiming alleged breach of covenants within the lease for extensions or other building work.

He was demanding residents pay £25,000 to buy out the freeholds, with the threat of forfeiture and High Court action if they do not pay up, she said. It is understood some leaseholders have paid.

Ms Blake said she reported him to police on the basis his actions “may amount to fraud by falsely representing the position of leaseholds, as well as causing intentional harassment, alarm or distress.”

Olivia Blake in the Commons.placeholder image
Olivia Blake in the Commons.

Raising the issue last month, she asked what steps the government was taking to “regulate rogue freeholders.”

Andrew Milne & Co, is based at Old Broad St, London.

His firm has previously denied any allegations of wrongdoing.

South Yorkshire Police said they were conducting a “fact-finding and scoping exercise” to determine if allegations against Andrew Milne met the criminal threshold.

A spokesperson said: “Since the reports relating to Andrew Milne came to light, we have been undertaking an extensive fact-finding and scoping exercise to build up a full picture of the circumstances surrounding the issues raised by a number of leaseholders in Sheffield.

“Once this scoping exercise is complete it will be determined if the allegations meet the criminal threshold, and whether SYP is the most appropriate authority to take this matter forward.”

The Solicitors Regulation Authority is also investigating Andrew Milne.

A spokesperson for the SRA said: “We can confirm we are investigating Mr Milne’s conduct and recognise the seriousness of the issues and allegations raised. Whilst the investigation progresses, we are urgently considering the imposition of interim conditions on his practising certificate for the purpose of protecting the public.”

The police say anyone who has received letters, emails, or any other form of correspondence from Andrew Milne should forward copies to [email protected]

Mr Milne was contacted for comment.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice