The Sheffield monster finally caught 25 years after a horrific rape and sexual attack on two teenage girls

Robert Wilson, who changed his name to Joshua The High Priest by deed poll, was jailed for 17 years in 2009

A Sheffield monster who evaded justice for sex attacks on two teenage girls for 25 years - despite being jailed twice for a rape and sexual assault in the intervening period - was eventually snared by DNA.

Robert Wilson, now aged 69, raped a girl aged 18 who he tricked into his car in October 1984 and then in June 1985 he put a 17-year-old female student through a horrific sexual attack at knifepoint.

Wilson was jailed for 17 years in 2009placeholder image
Wilson was jailed for 17 years in 2009 | SYP

Wilson, who changed his name to Joshua The High Priest by deed poll, was jailed for 17 years in 2009 after a cold case team from South Yorkshire Police began reviewing unsolved sex crimes carried out across the county.

Back in the 1980s, though he was arrested at the time for the second attack, Wilson was never charged because of insufficient evidence.

When he was finally brought to trial at Sheffield Crown Court in 2009 the jury heard Priest had a string of previous convictions for sexual offences.

He had been jailed for seven years in 1986 for raping and robbing a prostitute in Sheffield just weeks after the attack on the student. He was also jailed in 1993 for three years for the indecent assault of a 10-year-old girl.

The court heard in the 2009 trial how during the first attack in October 1984 Priest’s first victim got into his car after he tricked her into thinking he was a cab driver.

She gave him directions to her home but he drove the opposite way, stopped at a car park in Broomhall and raped her in the back of the car before dropping her off near Bramall Lane.

The rape was reported to the police but the court was told the girl didn’t want to continue with the police investigation. Following Priest’s attack, the girl became so distressed she twice attempted suicide.

The second attack happened eight months later when Priest broke into a flat in Broomhall along with an accomplice and woke a 17-year-old sixth form student who was staying with her boyfriend.

Priest armed himself with an ornamental dagger which was hanging on the wall and demanded money.

After her boyfriend had handed over his £150 coin collection, Priest took the girl down to the kitchen, swapped the dagger for a bread knife, then pinned her down and sexually assaulted her.

Sentencing him, Judge Graham Robinson said Priest had shown no remorse for his crimes.

South Yorkshire Police’s cold case review team was set up to review the most serious unsolved murders and rapes in the force area. They began to investigate the attacks carried out by Priest in 2007.

They used advances in scientific technology, such as DNA profiling which didn’t exist when Priest struck, and re-examined forensic evidence recovered from the crime scenes.

They were able to establish that the same man had been responsible for the attacks on both women.

When the officers checked the national DNA database they discovered the profiles recovered from the crime scene evidence in the 1980s matched that of Priest.

At the time of Priest’s conviction, Scientist Mike Wilson said: "DNA profiling technologies have advanced rapidly since the 1980s which allows us to re-examine materials retained from the original investigation.

"Low Copy Number DNA is our most sensitive DNA technique which can yield results from very small samples of DNA as well as old and degraded materials."

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice