Police issue statement after XL Bully is shot dead and Sheffield woman appears at court

Police bosses have explained why a decision was taken to shoot an XL Bully dead after it escaped from its home and ended up in a city street.

South Yorkshire Police issued a statement after the dog’s owner, Sophie Zaherali, appeared in court to be sentenced for owning a dog dangerously out of control.

Sophie Zaherali and Ghostplaceholder image
Sophie Zaherali and Ghost | Submit

She was also sentenced over online posts she shared in an attempt to identify the officer who killed her pet dog.

During a hearing in October, Sophie, aged 31, of Dykes Hall Road, Wisewood, pleaded guilty to the public communication offence but denied owning a dog dangerously out of control.

She was found guilty after a trial and appeared at Sheffield Magistrates’ Court yesterday to be sentenced.

Sophie ”was sentenced to a 24-month community order and was ordered to pay costs of £614.

Sophie Zaherali appeared at Sheffield Magistrates' Court wearing a hoodie bearing a picture of her XL Bully, Ghost, who escaped from a property and was shot dead by a police marksman.placeholder image
Sophie Zaherali appeared at Sheffield Magistrates' Court wearing a hoodie bearing a picture of her XL Bully, Ghost, who escaped from a property and was shot dead by a police marksman. | Sarah Marshall

Her dog, ‘Ghost’, became loose on Saturday, December 7, 2024.

Explaining what happened, South Yorkshire Police said: “Armed officers were dispatched to Dunella Road in the Hillsborough area after reports that a loose XL Bully had bitten a woman’s arm and acted aggressively towards another person walking their dog.

“Acting on intelligence received from the control room, officers arrived to find the dog roaming without an owner.

“As they exited their vehicle, the dog ran towards them, and the decision was made to shoot the dog in order to eliminate and reduce the risk it posed to the public.

“The decision to shoot a dog is never taken lightly; however, our officers are highly trained and experienced, required to make rapid judgments to safeguard their communities.

“Following the death of her dog, Zaherali shared images online in an attempt to identify the firearms officer involved.”

Firearms Inspector Steve Usher said: “As a dog owner you are the one responsible for your dog’s actions and the harm or fear they cause.

“To be a dog owner is a role of great responsibility and the consequences of slack ownership can be catastrophic.

“Sadly, across South Yorkshire we have experienced fatal dog attacks, and we make no apologies that our priority will always be the safety of the public and our officers.

“For over a year, officers have faced significant challenges during the investigation and court hearings into Ghost and Zaherali’s actions.

“I trust (the) sentencing demonstrates that owners will be held responsible for the impact of their choices.”

Sentencing Sophie, District Judge Tim Spruce said he believed her social media conduct, amounting to the malicious communication charge, was “borne out of grief and a desire to get justice for Ghost.”

He also said he believed her to be a responsible pet owner, and rejected calls from the prosecuting solicitor to ban her from keeping animals.

Judge Spruce described the case as “unusual,” stating that a “combination of circumstances” led to Ghost, a dog with no history of aggression or difficulties, being shot and killed on December 7, 2024.

He told the court that Sophie was attending to a child with vulnerabilities having a medical emergency when Ghost escaped.

She was “preoccupied” and a “faulty lock” to the door of the property allowed the dog to wander outside.

The judge acknowledged the court had no evidence to suggest Ghost was “behaving aggressively,” or that the police marksman dispatched to the scene witnessed him acting in such a way.

He noted, however, that whilst evidence of aggressive behaviour was not present, there were still circumstances that would have allowed the officer to “conclude he was dangerous.”

They included the two reports made to police that an XL Bully had become loose, causing concern to members of the public.

In addition, Judge Spruce said the officer had an “awareness of the nature of the breed” and the level of harm the dog was “potentially capable of.”

“The fact the dog ran towards the officer, there were circumstances to conclude he was dangerous,” Judge Spruce said.

He continued: “Having shot and killed Ghost, the officer was then subject to a campaign on social media, effectively asking for him to be exposed, identified and dismissed from his job.”

It has been an offence to own an XL Bully in the UK since February 1, 2024, for owners who do not have an exemption certificate and fail to adhere to strict conditions around muzzles and leads.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice