"Paranoid" Sheffield man who attacked police officer with axe may now be eligible for parole

Nathan Sumner struck PC Lisa Bates repeatedly with the weapon as she lay helpless after responding to a call at his home

A schizophrenic Sheffield man who attacked a female police officer with an axe leaving her fighting for her life in hospital may now be eligible for parole after serving nearly two-thirds of a 15-year sentence.

Nathan Sumner struck PC Lisa Bates repeatedly with the weapon as she lay helpless after responding to a call at his home in Plowright Close, Gleadless Valley, on April 13, 2016.

Nathan Sumner detained by police officers placeholder image
Nathan Sumner detained by police officers | Third party

In December that same year he was jailed for 15 years with an extra five years on licence and ordered to serve at least two thirds of his time in custody before being considered for release.

Sentencing him at Sheffield Crown Court in December 2016, Judge Julian Goose QC said: "It was truly shocking violence you used against PC Bates. One witness described you waiting for the officer to move her arms out of the way as she tried to defend herself while you rained down blows upon her.

"She begged you to stop and to let her go but you ignored her plea for mercy. She believed she was going to be killed by you as she was defenceless on the ground, unable to move away."

After admitting and being sentenced for grievous bodily harm with intent but acquitted of attempted murder, the then 36-year-old schizophrenic was transferred to a psychiatric hospital until doctors considered him fit to be transferred to prison.

The court heard how Sumner, who lived with his partner in a second-floor maisonette, had schizophrenia and in the days leading up to the attack his behaviour had been increasingly erratic and he had been displaying “paranoid thinking”.

Judge Goose said the defendant kept an axe at home which he used to strike at objects within the building and to threaten his girlfriend.

Police were called that day by a concerned neighbour and when PC Bates arrived with her colleague PC Mark Garrett, Sumner immediately attacked PC Garrett - only stopping after being sprayed in the face by PC Bates.

He then grabbed the axe and chased after the terrified officers brandishing the weapon. PC Bates broke her leg jumping down a staircase to escape him, and he stood over the defenceless officer as he struck her repeatedly with the axe.

He eventually stopped, dropped the weapon and walked to a nearby Co-op store, where it required several officers to detain him - one of whom was bitten in the process.

The court heard how PC Bates had to cancel her wedding and honeymoon due to her injuries.

She said at the time: "The physical effects of the incident include the inability to walk or use stairs on my own feet. My finger has not and probably won't regain its full range of motion.

"I continue to suffer from headaches, nausea, nightmares and flashbacks. Despite counselling I still struggle with sleeping, anxiety and depression. I have lost a dramatic amount of weight and am still taking several forms of medication."

She later left South Yorkshire Police.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice