The subject of online vigilante groups is in the news this week in Sheffield. In an incident on Monday, residents of a flat block were terrified when five men entered the building and roamed the corridors, banging on doors and claiming they were from a hunter group looking for a target. They left empty handed after menacing residents for 90 minutes.
These groups typically operate by using decoy profiles online to pose as underage children, then trapping offenders who send them lurid, sexually explicit texts. They sometimes pass this evidence on to the police first – but more often, it results in them luring the offender to a location and apprehending them. Or, they simply go to their house and often live stream the confrontation.
There is no law against entrapping paedophiles this way. However, the groups toe a line as they can slip into other illegal acts, such as of violence, extortion and blackmail. Or, they can end up publicly accusing the wrong person or confronting them with insufficient evidence.
As our gallery below shows, despite these methods, they do get results. These are just nine of dozens of cases seen in Sheffield Crown Court in the past two years where they were first arrested due to paedophile hunter groups.

9. Craig Burgin - sent indecent images of women, children and dogs to '13-year-old girl'
Craig Burgin, 41, of Stanwell Avenue, Wincobank, thought he was messaging 13-year-old girl "Jess" when he sent her indecent images of women, children and dogs to make conversation. Of course, Jess didn't exist and was really the profile of a paedophile hunter group. He was handed a suspended sentence and rehabilitation orders. - https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/sheffield-paedophile-caught-by-vigilante-sting-group-sent-explicit-images-to-13-year-old-girl-3463605 Photo: Chris Etchells

10. Kieran Hudson - detained at his home in sting
Kieran Hudson, aged 32, of Motehall Road, near Castlebeck, was detained at his home by online sting group Innocent Voices who set up a decoy account claiming to be a 12-year-old girl. Among the messages her sent her was a picture of his genitals and a bizzarre image of a naked woman with Homer Simpson's face on the body. He was handed a two-year community order. - https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/sheffield-paedophile-sent-customised-rude-image-of-homer-simpson-to-bogus-online-child-profile-3710635 Photo: Jon Cooper

11. Sheffield Crown Court
Mark Colton, aged 47, of Burns Road, Herringthorpe, Rotherham, was twice snared by a paedophile hunter group after members posed online with two bogus, decoy profiles claiming to be 13-year-old and 14-year-old girls. He was detained while trying to meet the first, and police alter found indecent images of children on his phone. He was jailed for two years. - https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/pervert-is-caged-after-being-snared-by-a-paedophile-hunter-group-3599037 Photo: Chris Etchells
![In 2019, the Recorder for Sheffield Judge Jeremy Richardson QC make his stance on paedophile hunter groups clear during the sentencing of Luke Kelly, 22, who was handed a suspended sentence for attempted sexual communication with a child.
Kelly was caught by online group "24/7 Paedophile Hunters". But in court, the judge said: "Chief constables around the country, courts around the country, including this court, make it clear that investigations and prosecutions for this form of criminality must be left to the professionals.
"Police officers and crown prosecutors understand the line between inciting a crime; encouraging a crime and that which is lawful."
Then, in another 2019 case, during the sentencing of Darren Smith, 44, of Priestly Avenue, Judge Richardson said: "This should have been handed over to the police. The vigilante group [Predator Exposure] aren't properly trained. They don't always understand the law." In this case, the court heard how, after the group's broadcast on social media, Priestly was seriously assaulted and subject to threats by the public.](https://www.thestar.co.uk/webimg/b25lY21zOmIxMGViZDA1LTI4ZjItNDliMS05ZDAwLWI3YzlhODRlYTUxOTo1ZjQxZjQwNS00Y2Q5LTQyOGEtYmJjOC1mOGZkZGJmYWJiZjk=.jpg?crop=4:3&trim=&width=640)
12. Recorder of Sheffield tells groups to "leave it to the professionals"
In 2019, the Recorder for Sheffield Judge Jeremy Richardson QC make his stance on paedophile hunter groups clear during the sentencing of Luke Kelly, 22, who was handed a suspended sentence for attempted sexual communication with a child. Kelly was caught by online group "24/7 Paedophile Hunters". But in court, the judge said: "Chief constables around the country, courts around the country, including this court, make it clear that investigations and prosecutions for this form of criminality must be left to the professionals. "Police officers and crown prosecutors understand the line between inciting a crime; encouraging a crime and that which is lawful." Then, in another 2019 case, during the sentencing of Darren Smith, 44, of Priestly Avenue, Judge Richardson said: "This should have been handed over to the police. The vigilante group [Predator Exposure] aren't properly trained. They don't always understand the law." In this case, the court heard how, after the group's broadcast on social media, Priestly was seriously assaulted and subject to threats by the public. Photo: Jon Cooper


