'Most wanted' Rotherham shoplifter jailed and barred from stores

A brazen shoplifter who stole goods worth more than £2,000 - said to be one of Rotherham’s most wanted offenders - has been banned from shops he targeted.

South Yorkshire Police described Michael Kelseall, aged 38, as one of the town’s most wanted shoplifters, as a result of a crime-spree between October and December last year.

Shoplifter Michael Kelseallplaceholder image
Shoplifter Michael Kelseall

He targeted shows across communities including Thrybergh, Swallownest, Herringthorpe and Aston.

He plundered a range of items, including coffee, biscuits, laundry products, meats and cheese.

All of these incidents were recorded on CCTV, allowing South Yorkshire Police to identify him.

On December 29, after conducting arrest attempts at several locations Kelseall was known to frequent, officers found him at a property in Thrybergh.

By that time, Kelseall’s haul of stolen goods was estimated to be worth approximately £2,400.

When questioned, Kelseall refused to provide a comment - ultimately leading him to be charged with 26 counts of theft from a shop and one charge of attempt from a shop.

Kelseall, of Hargrave Place, pleaded guilty to all counts at a hearing at Sheffield Magistrates' Court in January.

He has now appeared at the same court for sentencing and was jailed for 16 weeks and given a Criminal behaviour Order prohibiting him from entering any One Stop shop in Rotherham and remaining on any retail premises when asked to leave.

Police say working with local businesses and shop staff is integral in their work to tackle retail crime. “By sharing crucial information, photos and intelligence about shoplifters, we can be proactive and prevent thefts from happening,” said a spokesman.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice