Exclusive:Sheffield rogue trader Lucien Carter back in court and sentenced again over loft conversion lies
A rogue trader has appeared in court again.
A handyman has appeared in court again after another customer conned out out of cash came forward after seeing a report about the fraudster in The Star.
Rogue trader Lucien Carter, of Sandygate Road, was sentenced in 2024 for taking money from homeowners for projects then using every excuse in the book to avoid carrying out the work between 2022 and 2024.


In total, he took £26,000 from customers and fed them a series of lies including having paint stolen, losing the wallpaper he ordered at customs or forgetting bookings due to long Covid.
Whatever the reason, the now 57-year-old would then often ask for hundreds more from clients to solve these problems, only to either never finish the job or leave it “shoddy and to a very low standard.”
He was handed 18 months in prison suspended for two years with 200 hours of unpaid work.
Yesterday (April 28), Carter appeared back at Sheffield Crown Court, where a judge heard how, because of The Star’s reporting on the case in 2024, another customer had come forward with complaints from that same period.
“It was the exact same type of offending as before,” said prosecutor Mr Brian Outhwaite.
“He was engaged to complete work to a loft conversion. He was paid upfront for materials he never received, before requesting further money for scaffolding and other works.”
The court heard Carter span a story that he bought the materials needed from “a man named Gary” who had suddenly left for America and he would get the items once ‘Gary’ was back from the States.
Later, Carter admitted Gary never existed.
In sentencing, His Honour Judge Graham Reeds KC ruled that had the offence been heard along with the other cases in 2024, Carter “may” not have received a suspended sentence.
“However, your sentence was suspended. This was meant to provide a ‘last chance’ of rehabilitation,” the judge said.
“Your attempts at rehabilitation have been been patchy. You have not attended enough of your rehabilitation requirement days. Some of that is due to medical reasons, some not.
“But, to your credit, you have nearly completed all of your unpaid work.
“It seems to me that a further suspended sentence is a just and proportionate response.”
Carter was handed a further two years in prison, suspended for two years.
Editor’s note: A previous version of this story said Carter was sentenced by His Honour Judge Peter Hampton KC. This is not the case, as he was sentenced by His Honour Judge Graham Reeds KC. The story has been updated to reflect this.
