Breaking

Exclusive:Two men on trial for Darnall Christmas Day shooting acquitted of attempted murder over ‘weak evidence’

Two men have been acquitted of attempted murder after a man was seriously injured in a shooting in Darnall on Christmas Day. Rameel Mahmood and Samin Khan were today (November 17) acquitted of attempted murder after a young man was shot on Christmas Day 2026 in Wilfred Drive, Darnall. A judge ruled the evidence against them was "unquestionably weak."placeholder image
Two men have been acquitted of attempted murder after a man was seriously injured in a shooting in Darnall on Christmas Day. Rameel Mahmood and Samin Khan were today (November 17) acquitted of attempted murder after a young man was shot on Christmas Day 2026 in Wilfred Drive, Darnall. A judge ruled the evidence against them was "unquestionably weak." | Iconic Media Group, SYP

A judge said: “The case must be withdrawn from the jury. That is not a decision I have taken lightly”

Two men standing trial for attempted murder after a man who was shot on Christmas Day in Sheffield have been acquitted.

Just before 11.27pm on December 25, 2025, emergency services responded to reports that a 20-year-old man had been shot in the chest in Wilfred Drive, Darnall.

Rameel Mahmood and Samin Khan were today (November 17) acquitted of attempted murder after a young man was shot on Christmas Day 2026 in Wilfred Drive, Darnall. A judge ruled the evidence against them was "unquestionably weak."placeholder image
Rameel Mahmood and Samin Khan were today (November 17) acquitted of attempted murder after a young man was shot on Christmas Day 2026 in Wilfred Drive, Darnall. A judge ruled the evidence against them was "unquestionably weak." | SYP

Two men - Raheel Mahmood, 23, of Elmham Road, and Samin Khan, 23, of Basford Close, - were charged with the near lethal attack two weeks later.

But at Sheffield Crown Court on November 17, after over two weeks of evidence, a judge told the jury he was withdrawing the case and formally finding both men not guilty, ruling the evidence that identified them at the scene of the crime was “unquestionably weak.”

“I have had to direct the case must be stopped,” said The Recorder of Sheffield, His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson KC.

“The reason being the identification and recognition evidence you have heard is not of a strong character at all - in fact, it is quite weak.

“This is not a decision I have taken in haste.”

The scene in Wilfred Drive, Darnall, following the Christmas Day 2025 shooting which has left a 20-year-old male in a critical conditionplaceholder image
The scene in Wilfred Drive, Darnall, following the Christmas Day 2025 shooting which has left a 20-year-old male in a critical condition | Dave Higgens/PA Wire

What was the evidence?

Following the prosecution’s evidence ending last week, defence barristers Paul Lewis KC and Timothy Raggart KC moved there was no case to answer.

In the prosecution’s case, it was alleged Khan and the victim had a confrontation in the Darnall area over over one’s car blocking the other, later leading Khan to call Mahmood twice and collect him, find the man, and shoot him.

They then allegedly tracked the victim down with Khan as the driver of a grey VW Polo and Mahmood as the gunman.

Evidence included claims of recognising the men by two witnesses and the victim himself, the two calls the prosecution claimed were placed to Mahmood, and a can found in Khan’s Polo with one of Mahmood’s fingerprints on it.

The victim was in a critical condition for months and today has lost the use of his legs.placeholder image
The victim was in a critical condition for months and today has lost the use of his legs. | PA

Why was this evidence weak?

However, in a judgement read out in court on November 16, Judge Richardson ruled none of this was enough to convict the two men or present to a jury.

He said: “At the outset, this looked a reasonably cogent prosecution, with recognition and identification evidence that was not strong but adequate, and could be supported by other evidence.

“But the identification evidence is of a character which cannot be described as potent.”

Namely, the victim’s and a witness’ account identifying the shooter - who he said was Mahmood - was by the interior light of the car as they got out, which did not illuminate their face.

Further, the witness was looking over their shoulder at the time.

The Recorder of Sheffield, His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, today directed the jury to formerly find both men not guilty of attempted murder and end the trial.placeholder image
The Recorder of Sheffield, His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, today directed the jury to formerly find both men not guilty of attempted murder and end the trial. | Scott Merrylees

"The most either man could have seen of the one who opened fire was a maximum of four seconds, in the light from inside a car at night,” said the judge.

"The cross examination of two witnesses exposes the [weakness] of the evidence. It is, on examination, unquestionably poor.

"[As proceedings continued] I became more concerned that the case was no where near as cogent as before.

"The witnesses had convinced themselves of the evidence of their recognition, when on analysis it was very weak.”

Another issue was the revelation of a third call placed by Khan between the two supposedly placed to Mahmood, which was not brought up by the prosecution.

The judge said: "It's the defence saying, ‘the prosecution has cherry picked what suits their case and omitted what does not’.

"Without further and better investigation, the picture has real potential to be misleading or inaccurate. That would be wrong.”

And of the fingerprint on the can, the judge said: “When properly viewed it really adds up to nothing [as evidence]. Lots of people have debris in their car.

"The case must be withdrawn from the jury.

"That is not a decision I have taken lightly."

Updates to follow

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice