Exclusive:Sheffield man caught with 2,000 indecent images of children avoids prison
“I can fairly confidently predict that if you breach your terms, you will go to prison”
A man who was caught with more than 2,000 images of children he collected over 12 years was spared immediate prison.
Carl McLennan, formerly of Vicarage Close, Grenoside, was arrested at his home on November 15, 2023, after intelligence was passed to South Yorkshire Police.


The 62-year-old was caught with a library of vile images of child abuse, including 650 rated ‘Category A’, the worst grading available.
McLennan admitted what he did right there and then, as well as in a police interview later that same day.
He claimed he had downloaded them over the course of 12 years between 2011 and the day of his arrest. Multiple devices were seized.
“It’s fair to say the numbers involved were quite substantial, and over a sustained period of time,” said His Honour Judge Michael Slater KC at Sheffield Crown Court on July 6, 2026.
“In my view, this certainly crosses the custody threshold. The question for me is if it can be suspended.”
‘Perfidious trade’
The court heard McLennan, who now lives in St Ives, Cornwall, has engaged with multiple rehabilitation programmes since his arrest three years ago.
He also reportedly wrote a letter to the court about his offending.
The judge said: “There has been considerable delay in this case, which is not your fault. In this time, you have made positive efforts to rehabilitate yourself. That is to your credit.
“In your letter to the court, you correctly identify the harm that your behaviour has caused.
“Every time sometime someone downloads pictures of this kind, it encourages those who engage in this perfidious trade to expand it to other children.”
McLennan was sentenced to 14 months in prison, suspended for two years. He was also ordered to complete 40 days of rehabilitation work and handed a 10-year Sexual Harm Prevention Order.
Judge Salter warned: “I can fairly confidently predict that if you breach your terms, you will go to prison and I will reserve this case to me - I will not look kindly on throwing away this exceptional opportunity.”
