Sheffield man forced into bare-knuckle fighting by predatory crime gang who exploited him

A Sheffield man trafficked and exploited by an organised crime gang was forced into bare-knuckle fighting, a court has heard.

The claim was made as Gary McDonnell, aged 36, was brought before Sheffield Crown Court to be sentenced for assaulting a neighbour, along with four police officers - one of whom was left needing surgery.

Laying out McDonnell’s mitigation, Curtis Dunkley said that while nothing can excuse McDonnell’s violent behaviour, his numerous mental health problems including complex PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder) put it into “context.”

36-year-old Gary McDonnell was brought before Sheffield Crown Court to be sentenced for assaulting a neighbour, along with four police officers, one of whom was left needing surgery.placeholder image
36-year-old Gary McDonnell was brought before Sheffield Crown Court to be sentenced for assaulting a neighbour, along with four police officers, one of whom was left needing surgery. | Iconic Media

“He was trafficked, targeted by an OCG, forced into bare-knuckle fighting,” Mr Dunkley told the court, adding that some of the injuries McDonnell suffered in the illegal fighting have left him with a brain disorder.

Mr Dunkley continued: “This offending doesn’t arise out of criminal intent or hostility towards authority, but out of complex PTSD and cognitive impairment, affecting his responses to perceived threats.”

The five assaults committed by McDonnell, formerly of Leighton Road, Gleadless Valley, Sheffield, were committed over two separate incidents, with the first taking place on April 4, 2025.

“Police attended your address following reports of a disturbance. You were shouting from a balcony and threatening to throw yourself off,” the judge, Recorder Richard Paige, told McDonnell.

McDonnell was seen to be brandishing an object, believed to be either a stick or a bat, as he shouted down from the balcony at his property, prosecutor Sam Jones told the hearing.

The court heard how after resisting arrest and threatening to get “his dogs,” McDonnell slammed his front door against the ankle of one officer attending the incident, following which an officer deployed PAVA spray on McDonnell in an attempt to subdue him.

Mr Jones said McDonnell started to become non-responsive, but acted aggressively when he was roused, before blowing mucus and spit onto one of the arresting officers.

After being fitted with leg restraints and a “spit guard,” McDonnell was taken to hospital for treatment, where he assaulted a supervising officer by headbutting him to the stomach.

Later, when McDonnell was transferred to custody, Mr Jones said he assaulted another officer there by kicking him.

Following his release from custody, McDonnell committed a further two assaults some four months later on August 5, 2025.

Describing what happened next, Recorder Paige told McDonnell: “You became involved in a dispute with your neighbour about noise. You smashed your own window, and caused glass to rain down on her and her grandchildren. You threatened her with a weapon described as an axe or a hammer.”

The hearing heard how McDonnell’s neighbour suffered a number of small cuts to her face, caused by the shattered glass from his broken window.

A police officer was subsequently dispatched to the scene, and as he made an attempt to arrest him, McDonnell punched him to the nose, causing his cartilage to become dislodged from his skull.

In a statement to the court, the officer said he is now awaiting surgery for his injury. He said the injury is preventing him from doing his job to the best of his ability adding: “I do not expect or accept being violently assaulted when I’m just doing my job.”

McDonnell was charged with, and pleaded guilty to, one count of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, one count of assault by beating and three counts of assaulting an emergency worker at an earlier hearing.

Mr Jones told the court that McDonnell has a criminal record spanning 71 offences from 31 convictions, with a number of previous entries for violent offences including battery and assaulting an emergency worker. He was also the subject of a community order imposed in February 2025 when he committed his most recent set of offences.

Continuing in his mitigation, Mr Dunkley said: “Mr McDonnell knows his behaviour on each occasion was unacceptable. He entered guilty pleas at the first opportunity and expressed genuine remorse in his conferences with me today.”

Mr Dunkley told the court that McDonnell has attempted to cope with the trauma he has endured throughout his life by self-medicating with drugs and alcohol because he “didn’t know any better.”

McDonnell, claimed Mr Dunkley, had continued to receive threats at his home address from the OCG which trafficked and exploited him, making him feel “unsafe,” and contributing to his offending behaviour; but he has now been able to secure new accommodation.

Mr Dunkley said the accommodation, along with the progress he has been able to make with a psychiatrist, would all be lost should he receive a custodial sentence.

He acknowledged that McDonnell is deemed to pose a high risk of reoffending, but said that risk only exists whilst he is under the thrall of drugs and alcohol, and McDonnell has managed to get himself clean of all substances whilst in custody on remand.

McDonnell, who appeared at court via a prison video link, could be seen holding up certificates confirming his abstinence from drugs and alcohol in custody, at several points during his sentencing hearing.

Passing sentence, Recorder Paige handed down a sentence of 24 months’ custody suspended for 24 months.

He warned McDonnell, however: “You’ve been given a chance today. This suspended sentence will be hanging over you, and if you breach the order or commit any further offences you will go to prison.”

As part of McDonnell’s order, he will be required to complete a six-month alcohol treatment programme.

Recorder Paige also ordered a restraining order, prohibiting McDonnell from contacting the neighbour he assaulted.

As he learned he would soon be freed from custody, McDonnell told Recorder Paige: “I’m sorry to everyone...I’m not going to be here again, I’m going to get off drugs and alcohol...I’m actually proud of myself for once.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice