Sheffield conman stole over £20,000 from old pal - taking monthly scam mortgage payments for three years

Victim described feeling “shame” that he had fallen for the scam

A Sheffield conman pilfered over £20,000 from an old pal by offering to line-up a house purchase with a fictitious solicitor and pocketing the scam mortgage repayments himself.

Andrew Webster, aged 47, took monthly payments of £500 from the complainant - who he had known for “a number of years” - for over three years.

Webster’s jail term was suspended placeholder image
Webster’s jail term was suspended | Iconic

Webster offered to land him a loan to purchase his father’s council house under the Right To Buy scheme, recommending a solicitor who would manage the repayments.

Ella Fornsworth, prosecuting, described how after agreeing to the deal in July 2020 the complainant was contacted by someone purporting to be a solicitor, who claimed “payment had been received” by the council for his father’s property.

However in November 2023 the ‘solicitor’ became “frustrated” by the victim’s attempts to contact him and “terminated” the repayment agreement, which finally aroused suspicion.

Ms Fornsworth said: “When (the complainant) asked to meet the solicitor, excuses were offered as to why this was not possible.

“The solicitor never answered when called but in November 2023 he became frustrated by the repeated attempts to contact him and terminated the agreement.”

In a statement read to the court, the victim described feeling “shame” that he had fallen for the scam and explained he was now being unable to get a real mortgage for the property as it had increased in value by £50,000 over the three-year period.

Andrew Webster leaving Sheffield Crown Court placeholder image
Andrew Webster leaving Sheffield Crown Court | Iconic

By the time Webster’s pal contacted the police he had paid the defendant £21,407, said Ms Fornsworth.

Webster had a previous motoring conviction and a police caution for fraud on his record, the court heard.

A barrister representing the defendant said he had been struggling financially at the time and his relationship was ending.

She said the fraudster, who was diagnosed with testicular cancer in 2023, “regrets his actions and accepts he will never be able to right his wrongs”.

Recorder Anna Moran told Webster “(The complainant) trusted you and as a result you told him you would help him purchase the property under Right To Buy - you took advantage.

“Of course he could not meet the solicitor because it was all part of your fraudulent scheme during the course of three years.”

The judge suspended a two-year jail term for two years, ordering Webster to pay £16,000 compensation from his savings.

Webster, of Castle Croft Lane, Bolsterstone, was also handed 200 hours of unpaid work, 10 rehabilitation activity days and a five-month curfew.

He admitted fraud.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice