Man stabbed to death by love rival in Sheffield knife attack, murder trial told
A Sheffield man died after being stabbed in his heart by a love rival, the jury in a murder trial has been told.
Bradley Hollis, aged 35, died during an incident on Barlow Drive, Stannington, in the early hours of Sunday, March 16, 2025.
Michael James is accused of Mr Hollis’ murder and possessing a bladed article in a public place, both of which he denies.
He has today (Tuesday, September 30, 2025) gone on trial at Sheffield Crown Court after pleading not guilty.


Jurors have been told that Mr James, 45, claims that Mr Hollis “must have inadvertently stabbed himself” during the course of the violence that unfolded during a brief tussle lasting for one minute and 51 seconds.
But prosecutor Richard Thyne KC said it is the Crown’s case that the three stab wounds Mr Hollis suffered in his final moments - along with “defensive” slash wounds to his “upper limbs and face” - were inflicted by Mr James, making him guilty of murder.
“We say you can reject it as untrue because of the you know from what the pathologist found that there were multiple severe injuries to separate parts of the body involving not only three separate stab wounds but slash wounds to the upper limbs and face - some of them consistent with being defensive,” Mr Thyne said.
He told the jury that during the course of the trial they may hear arguments advanced on Mr James’ behalf claiming that his actions on the night were self defence.
Mr Thyne added, however, such a defence can only succeed for someone who has used “reasonable” force in order to protect themselves.
“The prosecution case is inflicting multiple injuries with a knife and leaving someone on the floor to die, as well as removing the only means for calling an ambulance could never ever be reasonable and that’s why the defendant can’t bring himself to admit that he stabbed and slashed at Bradley so many times,” he said.
The court heard how the scene for the violence which cost Mr Hollis his life was the family home of Mr James, Zara Tolley and her four children.
Opening the prosecution case, Mr Thyne said Mr James and Ms Tolley had been in a relationship for around 10 to 11 years, during which they had two children, and had planned to marry in 2024.
However, instead of marrying, the pair split up last year, but Mr James continued living at the family home, until the date of the fatal incident.
During 2024, Ms Tolley also entered into a new relationship with Mr Hollis.
The prosecutor characterised both of the relationships as “unhealthy,” with both men arrested for violence towards Ms Tolley in separate incidents.
Mr James, the jury was told, attacked Ms Tolley during a family event, and was alleged to be responsible for a deterioration in both her “mental health and physical cleanliness,” according to evidence provided by her sister.
It was claimed Ms Tolley was also believed to have been mistreated by Mr Hollis, who was alleged to have thrown a hammer through the window of the family home, and to have assaulted her in Blackpool, with the latter incident resulting in social services becoming involved.
“It was against that backdrop that the jealous, controlling and sometimes violent nature of both men formed a catalyst for what was to occur,” explained the prosecutor.
The jury were read messages sent from Mr James to Ms Tolley in the weeks leading up to Mr Hollis’ death.
One such message read: “I’m telling you now, if that w****r comes anywhere near my kids, I’ll kill you both. And don’t think I won’t because I will.”
Jurors heard that in the hours leading up to the early-hours attack, Ms Tolley was home with Mr James, and was exchanging messages with Mr Hollis.
“She described he snatched the phone from her, demanding to know who she had been messaging. He threw the phone from the upstairs window, and also assaulted her a number of times, punching her a number of times and hitting her over the head with a bottle,” Mr Thyne said.
Mr James subsequently took Ms Tolley’s phone, left the property and locked the door behind him.
He observed events at the property using live footage on the property’s doorbell camera, watching the comings and goings, and listening to audio from within the property, while he was located in an outbuilding positioned near to allotments at Rivelin Valley Park, the court heard.
Mr James also issued a number of threats to Ms Tolley during phone conversations after he left the property, the court was told.
Jurors heard that Ms Tolley subsequently escaped from the property, and went to a nearby friend’s house, while a taxi was called to bring Mr Hollis to the house.
Ms Tolley and her friend were waiting for Mr Hollis when Mr James returned to the property a matter of minutes before Mr Hollis was due to arrive.
A scuffle ensued between the two men after Mr Hollis entered the property through the living room window, the jury has been told.
Both of the eye witnesses, Ms Tolley and her friend, described Mr James and Mr Hollis fighting with their fists, with neither man initially taking the upper hand.
Mr Thyne said both eye-witnesses watched as Mr James took a knife from the kitchen, following which Mr Hollis suffered a number of stab and slash wounds. Ms Tolley said she did not see Bradley being stabbed.
Her friend, the other eye-witness, said she saw Mr James “making two or three upper cut motions” as he stabbed Mr Hollis.


Pathologist Dr Charles Wilson said Mr Hollis suffered a fatal wound to his heart, inflicted with sufficient “force” to cut through breast bone. The other stab wounds were located on his left shoulder and rib cartilage.
Despite the best efforts of the paramedics who tried to save Mr Hollis’ life, he was pronounced dead at 3.39am that morning.
Mr James left the scene exactly one minute and 51 seconds after Mr Hollis entered the property, and took the knife allegedly used in the attack, along with the borrowed phone Ms Tolley had been using after he stole hers, with him, the court heard.
He went back to the outbuilding near to Rivelin Valley Park and watched on the family’s doorbell camera as the emergency services arrived on the scene, said Mr Thyne, adding that police found him using the stolen phone’s location data in the outbuilding shortly after 4am.
Mr Thyne continued: “He was no longer in possession of the knife, but it was found by a member of the public. It was seen in the river that runs through the park.”
Crime scene investigators subsequently found a knife as they retrieved jogging bottoms which had been cut from Mr Hollis, as medics worked on him. Neither of the eye-witnesses, or Mr James, reported seeing Mr Hollis with a knife, the jury was told. The pockets of Mr Hollis’ jogging bottoms were zipped up, noted Mr Thyne.
He added: “The prosecution say in reality it is likely the knife was being carried by Bradley...what’s also clear is that Bradley Hollis never produced the knife during the course of this incident.”
“We tell you about that knife because it’s important when you assess this case you have a fair picture of both of the men. In reality, you know that knife played no physical role in the events that occurred during the early hours of that morning.”
The jury were told they are set to hear from Dr Wilson, who has described Mr James’ claim that the fatal wound was caused when Mr Hollis “effectively impaled” himself on the knife as being “implausible.”
Concluding his opening outline of the prosecution case, Mr Thyne told the jury: “The prosecution say whatever Bradley’s faults, and whatever you may think about some of his actions, [from what] you have heard - and will continue to hear - you can be sure he was murdered.”
Mr James has admitted a charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm in relation to the injuries caused to Ms Tolley.
He denies one count of murder, and one count of possessing a bladed article in a public place.