Gary Hutton:Pervert paramedic planned to sexually abuse young girls after meeting their mums on swingers' site
A paramedic discussed his sickening plans to groom and sexually abuse three young girls, one of whom was just six-years-old, after meeting their mothers on a swingers’ dating site.
As he sent 59-year-old Gary Hutton to begin a prison sentence, Judge David Dixon said he was satisfied the discussions were not just fantasies - as Hutton had later claimed - and that he would have carried out the plans had he been given the opportunity.
“You claimed this was no more than fantasy. I do not accept that. The kind of conversations you were having, the fact you were engaging with three different - as far as you were concerned - real women and purported it had happened before all leads to this being a genuine desire in your life. A genuine desire to have sex with a child,” Judge Dixon told Hutton.


A Sheffield Crown Court hearing on November 18, 2025, heard how one of the three women Hutton discussed the sexual abuse with was an undercover police officer, whilst the other two are believed to have been real women with children.
In the case of all three women, Hutton struck up online communications with them after meeting them through an online swingers’ dating site, aimed at people interested in swapping sexual partners, and initiated conversations by asking them what their kinks were, and if they were interested in breaking “taboos.”
Hutton, who qualified as a paramedic in 2013, also told the women he had previously been asked to “educate” the 13-year-old daughter of a couple he had been speaking to online through sexual abuse, but they subsequently backed out.
Nicola Quinney, prosecuting, said the undercover officer told Hutton that her daughter was six-years-old, while the two “real” women said their daughters were aged seven and 12.
During the conversations with the undercover officer, Hutton proceeded to talk about the graphic sexual things he wanted to do to.
He subsequently talked about meeting up on his day off, after revealing he did not want his wife or his work to find out about the plans.
Following this conversation, police acted quickly to arrest Hutton within hours at his workplace at an ambulance training centre on February 26, 2025.
Ms Quinney said Hutton’s devices, including his mobile phone, were seized during the course of his arrest, and revealed the near-identical conversations he had been having with two other mothers.
“You were in effect talking about a process of how you would be allowed to have sex with their children, claiming you had been asked before to have sex with a 13-year-old by her parents but they backed out,” Judge Dixon told Hutton.
One of the “real” women told Hutton she had an 18-month-old baby, and sent Hutton a picture of the tot, to which he replied “very nice.”
The two real women and Hutton also engaged in a group message, during which he told them he wanted to have sex with them and their young daughters.
“The level of conversations, the number of conversations, the very grim nature of the conversations is troubling in the extreme,” continued Judge Dixon.
Hutton, of Bootham Crescent, Stainforth, Doncaster, pleaded guilty to two counts of attempting to arrange/ facilitate commission of a child sex offence during the course of a hearing held four days before his trial was due to begin.
Defending, James Holding drew Judge Dixon’s attention to the fact Hutton had a clean criminal record prior to these offences, along with an “unblemished” 28-year career in the NHS, starting in an Ambulance Service control room.
“He accepts the offending in its entirety,” Mr Holding said, but added: “This is not a case where he was only stopped from carrying out the offences by police intervention.”
Judge Dixon disagreed with this assertion, and told Hutton: “I’ve no doubt if the real women said: ‘please come and see me,’ you would have gone, and you would have carried out the fantasies you described, in relation to very young children.”
Mr Holding continued by saying Hutton was supported in court by his wife, who suffers from a condition which often leaves her reliant on Hutton for her day-to-day needs.
Mr Holding read a reference to the court from a school friend of Hutton’s who has known him for 40 years, since the pair undertook the Duke of Edinburgh Award Scheme together.
The friend spoke positively of Hutton’s character, adding that he was aware of the charges he faced but believed they were “out of character for the person I’ve known all this time.”
Jailing Hutton for 10 years, Judge Dixon said he believed the former paramedic posed such a danger to the public that an extended licence period of five years - bringing his total sentence to one of 15 years - was necessary.
He told Hutton, who will be required to serve two-thirds of his 10-year custodial sentence behind bars: “Here the children were particularly vulnerable because their mothers, the very people who should have been protecting them, were handing them out to be used and abused.”
Hutton was also made the subject of a 15-year sexual harm prevention order.
Speaking after Hutton was jailed, Detective Constable Becky Straw, from South Yorkshire Police’s Online Sexual Offences team, said: “Hutton’s offending is extremely disturbing, and I am relieved that he was caught before it had the opportunity to progress further.
“I am incredibly proud of our Internet Sex Offences Team (ISOT) officers who carry out vital work behind the scenes to keep children in our community safe from those who would do them unconscionable harm.


“ISOT acted swiftly, arresting Hutton within 24 hours of him engaging with our decoy, and seizing his devices so that evidence into his disgusting offending could be preserved.
“Hutton is now safely behind bars, and ISOT are hard at work ensuring that other offenders like him are caught and brought to justice.”
Yorkshire Ambulance Service has been contacted for comment.