Speaking to the transport committee, Sir David said that ‘massive expenditure’ would have been required to make such a line viable.
An original route would have seen the line go between Rotherham and Sheffield with a new station being built at Meadowhall. But these plans were scrapped earlier this year in favour of the new spur route between Rotherham and Doncaster with trains instead stopping at the existing station in Sheffield city centre. The Government said the change of plan could save £1 billion and a decision is due next year.
*A record number of entries ensured it was the biggest and best Sheffield Business Awards for many a year.
More than 700 people attended a gala ceremony at Ponds Forge hosted by BBC Look North legend Harry Gration as a total of 15 awards were handed out.
Lakeside Doncaster: Major search launched by emergency services after man gets into difficulty in water
Popple Street Sheffield: 'Several' people arrested as street is cordoned off by police
Sheffield weather: Met Office issues thunderstorm warning as heatwave set to end with heavy rain and lightning
South Yorkshire heatwave: 'Avoid the area' warning as five crews tackle large wildfire
Yorkshire Natural History Museum: New Sheffield museum in Malin Bridge is big success on opening morning
The coveted Business Person of the Year Award went to Arnie Singh, managing director of City Taxis. Meanwhile, the Outstanding Business of the Year trophy was awarded to engineering firm Tinsley Bridge.
*Tears flowed and emotions ran high as an army of inspirational youngsters were celebrated at the Sheffield Star Superkids Awards 2016.
Extraordinary stories of bravery, dedication and achievement from youngsters who have overcome adversity brought tears, smiles and celebrations in the audience at a glittering ceremony held at Outwood Academy City.
In a moving ceremony, the packed audience heard stories about how a number of youngsters are bravely managing to keep a smile while battling serious illness.
Other tales that tugged at the heart strings included that of Family Award winner Jenson Lomas, who has been staying strong for his mum, dad and sister while his mum was undergoing treatment for breast cancer.
*Hero lifeguard Hayden Liggins was praised for saving the life of a toddler after she was pulled unconscious from a Sheffield swimming pool. The drama unfolded at Ponds Forge International Sports Centre.